The Renaissance of Political Realism in Early Modern Europe: Giovanni Botero and the Discourse of “Reason of State”

Ferenc Hörcher

Abstrakt

The purpose of this paper is to reconstruct a type of early modern political realism that is perhaps less widely researched in the English language scholarly context than the main stream Machiavellian type. The Italian ex-Jesuit, Giovanni Botero’s book Della Ragion di Stato (1589) is a fascinating experiment to combine some of the basic insights into arcana imperii (secrets of the state/power) made famous by the Florentine, and a refashioned Catholic teaching, as it was presented by the Jesuits. The paper tries to show the author’s motivations and his main line of argumentation. The paper starts out with a historiographical overview of the state of the art in the field of the history of political realism, focusing on two representatives of the so-called Cambridge School, Richard Tuck and István Hont. This is followed by a short reconstruction of some of the key terms of Botero’s treatise, based on the assumption that the history of ideas has to concentrate on the discourse used in a given context by the particular political agent or theorist. Next, certain contexts of Botero’s thought are examined, including 16th century Tacitism, Lipsius, and the Jesuit tradition with its links to the Salamanca school. Finally, one of Botero’s key concepts, the virtue of prudence is analysed, showing the deep-seated connections between Botero’s political realism and the ancient Greek, Roman, and Catholic traditions of practical philosophy. A postscript links the early modern discourse with the birth of the study of international relations.
 

Słowa kluczowe: Botero, Machiavelli, realizm polityczny, roztropność, tacytyzm, Lipsjusz, Salamanka, stosunki międzynarodowe
References

Sources

Aristotle, Politics, transl. by B. Jowett, Kitchener 1999.

Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, transl. by W.D. Ross, Kitchener 1999.

Botero G., De regia sapientia, Mediolani 1583.

Botero G., Della Ragion di Stato, Venetia 1589.

Botero G., Delle cause della grandezza e magnificenza delle città, Roma 1588.

Botero G., Relazioni Universali, Roma 1591.

Botero G., The Reason of State, transl. by P.J. and D.P. Waley with an intr. by D.P. Waley, and The Greatness of Cities (1606), transl. by R. Peterson, New Haven 1956.

Botero G., Raison et gouvernement d’Estat, en dix livres. Du seigneur Giovani Botero Benese. Traduicts sur la quatriesme impression italienne, plus ample que les autres premieres, la version respondant à son original, colomne, pour colomne, par Gabriel Chappuys secretaire, interprete du roy & dediez a monsieur d’Incarville, Paris 1599.

Castiglione B., The Book of the Courtier, a new transl. by Ch.S. Singleton, Garden City 1959.

Gracián B., El héroe, Madrid 1637.

Lipsius J., De constantia in publicis malis, Antwerp 1583/1584.

Lipsius J., Politicorum sive Civilis doctrinae libri sex, Leiden 1589.

Livius T., The History of Rome, 1–8, London 1853.

Metternich C., Mémoires, documents et écrits divers laissés par le Prince de Metternich. Publiés par son fils le Prince Richard de Metternich, classés et réunis par M.A. de Klinkowstroem, Paris 1884.

Richelieu A.J., Testament politique d’Armand du Plessis, Cardinal duc de Richelieu, Paris 1680.

Literature

A koramodern politikai eszmetörténet Cambridge-i látképe: John Dunn, John G.A. Pocock, Quentin Skinner és Richard Tuck tanulmányai, F. Horkay Hörcher (ed.), Pécs 1997.

Bireley R., The Counter-Reformation Prince: Anti-Machiavellianism or Catholic Statecraft in Early Modern Europe, Chapel Hill 1990.

Bireley R., The Refashioning of Catholicism, 1450–1700: A Reassessment of the Counter Reformation, Washington 1999.

Bobbit Ph., The Shield of Achilles: War, Peace, and the Course of History, New York 2002.

Bobroff E., The Earthly Structures of Divine Ideas: Influences on the Political Economy of Giovanni Botero, unpublished thesis: http://ecommons.usask.ca/bitstream/handle/10388/etd-08082005-135926/copyrightthesis.pdf?sequence=1 (10.12.2015).

Borzsák I., A tacitizmus kérdéséhez [in:] Dragma. Válogatott tanulmányok, Budapest 1994.

Brooke Ch., Philosophic Pride: Stoicism and Political Thought from Lipsius to Rousseau, Princeton 2012.

Burke P., Tacitism, scepticism, and reason of state [in:] The Cambridge History of Political Thought, 1450–1700,J.H. Burns (ed.), Cambridge 1991, p. 479–498.

Burke P., The Fortunes of the Courier: The European Reception of Castiglione’s Cortegiano, Cambridge 1995.

Church W., Richelieu and “Reason of State”, Princeton 1972.

Cosgrove D., Globalism and Tolerance in Early Modern Geography, “Annals of the Association of American Geographers” 2003, Vol. 93, No. 4, p. 852–870.

Descendre R., L’état du monde: Giovanni Botero entre Raison d’État et géopolitique,Genève 2009.

Dunn J., Western Political Theory in the Face of the Future, Cambridge 1979.

Farrell A.P., The Jesuit Ratio Studiorum of 1599: Translated into English, with an Introduction and Explanatory, Detroit 1970, http://www.bc.edu/sites/libraries/ratio/ratio1599 (10.12.2015).

Finkelstein A., Harmony and the Balance: An Intellectual History of Seventeenth-Century English Economic Thought, Ann Arbor 2000.

Forbes D., Hume’s Philosophical Politics, Cambridge 1975.

Gulick E., Europe’s Classical Balance of Power, New York 1967.

Hont I., Jealousy of Trade: International Competition and the Nation-State in Historical Perspective, Cambridge 2005.

Hont I., Politics in Commercial Society: Jean-Jacques Rousseau and Adam Smith, B. Kapossy, M. Sonenscher (eds.), Cambridge 2015.

Hont I., Ignatieff M., Wealth and Virtue: The Shaping of Political Economy in the Scottish Enlightenment, Cambridge 1983.

Horkay Hörcher F., Államrezon és konzervativizmus, “Kommentár”2007, Vol. 6, p. 50–71.

Horkay Hörcher F., Eszmetörténeti bevezetés a globális kapitalizmus gazdaságtanába, “Élet és Irodalom”2006, Vol. 50, No. 8; www.es.hu/horkay_horcher_ferenc;eszmetorteneti_bevezetes;2006-02-26.html (10.12.2015).

Horkay Hörcher F., Prudencia, kairosz, decorum. A konzervativizmus időszemléletéről (Prudence, Kairos, Decorum: Of the Temporal Thinking of Conservatism), “Információs társadalom: társadalomtudományi folyóirat” 2006, 6 (4), p. 61–80.

Kissinger H., The Conservative Dilemma: Reflections on the Political Thought of Metternich, “The American Political Science Review”1954, Vol. 48, No. 4, p. 1017–1030.

Kissinger H., A World Restored: Metternich, Castlereagh and the Problems of Peace, 1812–1822, Boston 1957.

Lineages of Empire: The Historical Roots of British Imperial Thought, D. Kelly (ed.),Oxford 2009.

Long D., Schmidt B.C., Imperialism and Internationalism in the Discipline of International Relations,Albany 2005.

McCourt D., What’s at Stake in the Historical Turn? Theory, Practice and Phronēsisin International Relations, “Millennium: Journal of International Studies”2012, Vol. 41 (1), p. 23–42.

Metternich C., Memoires, documents et écrits divers laisses par le Prince de Metternich, chancelier de cour et d’Etat,Paris 1881–1886.

Momigliano A., Tacitus and the Tacitist Tradition: The Foundations of Modern Historiography, Berkeley 1990.

Momigliano A., The First Political Commentary on Tacitus, “The Journal of Roman Studies”,Vol. 37, No. 1–2,p. 99–101.

Pagden A., Lords of All the World: Ideologies of Empire in Spain, Britain and France c. 1500–1800, London–New Haven 1995.

Papy J., Justus Lipsius [in:] The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, http://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2011/entries/justus-lipsius/ (10.12.2015).

Pocock J.G.A., The Machiavellian Moment: Florentine Political Thought and the Atlantic Republican Tradition, Princeton 1975.

Poole T., Reason of State: Law, Prerogative, Empire, Cambridge 2015.

Pounds N.J.G., A Historical Geography of Europe, 1500–1840, Cambridge 1978.

Schellhase K.C., Botero, “Reason of State”, and Tacitus [in:] Botero e La “Ragion di Stato”: Atti dei Convegni in Memoria di Luigi Firpo,A.E. Baldini (ed.),Firenze 1992.

Schellhase K.C., Tacitus in Renaissance Political Thought, Chicago 1976.

Skinner Q., The Foundations of Modern Political Thought, Cambridge 1978.

Thumfart J., Die Begründung der globalpolitischen Philosophie: Zu Francisco de Vitorias “relectio de indis recenter inventis” von 1539,Berlin 2009.

Tuck R., Natural Rights Theories: Their Origin and Development, Cambridge 1979.

Tuck R., Philosophy and Government, Cambridge 1993.

Viroli M., From Politics to “Reason of State”: The Acquisition and Transformation of the Language of Politics 1250–1600, Cambridge 1992.

Kwartalnik ukazuje się w sposób ciągły on-line.
Pierwotną wersją czasopisma jest wersja elektroniczna publikowana w internecie.