The Role of Non-State Actors in the Cultural Heritage Field – The Case of the Orthodox Church and Its Heritage in Turkey

Nicholas Augustinos

Abstrakt

The involvement of non-state actors in legal regimes concerning the protection of cultural heritage has been identified as a key challenge facing the development of international law in this field. This challenge is intensified when the relevant cultural heritage under consideration takes the form of religious sites whose use by a church community (non-state actor) for the purposes of its religious activities has been impacted upon by circumstances such as war or inter-ethnic conflict resulting in the displacement of that church community. This article contributes to this discussion by reference to a significant non-state actor in the field of religion and global affairs – the Orthodox Church – and specifically by reference to the Church’s heritage in Turkey. After providing the reasons which justify a scholarly legal examination of the Church’s assertion of rights with respect to its heritage in Turkey, as well as an outline of the main measures which have been applied by Turkish authorities to this heritage, the article proceeds to offer a tentative overview and analysis of the relevant legal and policy framework and suggests certain issues requiring further scholarly exploration. It is argued that in addition to providing useful insights about the role of nonstate actors in the cultural heritage field, such further exploration can offer useful insights about a related topic which is currently relatively unexplored by cultural heritage commentators, namely, the post-conflict management of religious sites.

Słowa kluczowe: cultural heritage law, religious heritage, non-state actors, Orthodox Church
References

Abtahi H., The Protection of Cultural Property in Times of Armed Conflict: The Practices of the International Criminal Tribunal of the Former Yugoslavia, “Harvard Human Rights Journal” 2001, Vol. 14.

Bailliet C.M. (ed.), Non-State Actors, Soft Law and Protective Regimes: From the Margins, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2012.

Bianchi A. (ed.), Non-State Actors and International Law, Ashgate, Farnham 2009.

Blake J., International Cultural Heritage Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2015.

Boylan P.J., The Concept of Cultural Protection in Times of Armed Conflict: From the Crusades to the New Millennium, in: N. Brodie, K.W. Tubb (eds.), Illicit Antiquities, Routledge, London 2003.

Chechi A., Beyond Protection: Cooperation as a Tool to Cope with Unresolved Cultural Heritage Issues in Post-Conflict Cyprus, “American Society of International Law Cultural Heritage & Arts Review” 2011, Vol. 2(1).

Chechi A., Non-State Actors and Cultural Heritage: Friends or Foes?, “Anuario de la Facultad de Derecho de la Universidad Autonoma de Madrid” 2015, Vol. 19.

Clapham A., Human Rights Obligations of Non-State Actors, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2006.

Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, 14 May 1954, 249 UNTS 240.

Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, 4 November 1950, ETS 5, as amended.

Council of Europe/European Court of Human Rights, Guide on Article 9 of the European Convention on Human Rights: Freedom of Thought, Conscience and Religion, 2015.

D’Aspremont J. (ed.), Participants in the International Legal System, Routledge, London 2011.

Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination on Religion or Belief, 25 November 1981, A/RES/36/55.

Detling K.J., Eternal Silence: The Destruction of Cultural Property in Yugoslavia, “Maryland Journal of International Law & Trade” 1993, Vol. 17.

Ecumenical Patriarchate website, http://www.patriarchate.org [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Erasing the Christian Past – A Fine Byzantine Church in Turkey has been Converted into a Mosque, “The Economist”, 27 July 2013, http://www.economist.com/node/21582317/print [accessed: 3.05.2019].

European Centre For Law & Justice, ECLJ Welcomes the ECHR Decision in the Christian Orphanage Case v. Turkey, https://eclj.org/eclj-welcomes-the-echr-decision-in-the-christian-orphanage-case-v-turkey [accessed: 8.04.2019].

European Commission for Democracy Through Law (Venice Commission), Opinion on the Legal Status of Religious Communities in Turkey and the Right of the Orthodox Patriarchate of Istanbul to Use the Adjective “Ecumenical”, Opinion No. 535/2009, Strasbourg, 15 March 2010, CDL-AD(2010)005.

European Court of Human Rights, Bozcaada Kimisis Teodoku Rum Ortodoks Kilisesi Vakfi v. Turkey, Application Nos 37639/03, 37655/03, 26736/04, and 42670/04, Judgment of 3 March 2009.

European Court of Human Rights, Cha’are Shalom Ve Tsedek v. France, Application No. 27417/95, Judgment of 27 June 2000.

European Court of Human Rights, Chrysostomos v. Turkey, Application No. 66611/09, Decision of inadmissibility of 4 January 2011.

European Court of Human Rights, Fener Rum Erkek Lisesi Vakfi v. Turkey, Application No. 34478/97, Judgment of 9 January 2007.

European Court of Human Rights, Fener Rum Patrikliği (Ecumenical Patriarchy) v. Turkey, Application No. 14340/05, Judgment of 8 July 2008.

European Court of Human Rights, Metropolitan Church of Bessarabia v. Moldova, Application No. 45701/99, Judgment of 13 December 2001.

European Court of Human Rights, Pavlides and Georgakis v. Turkey, Application Nos 9130/09 and 9143/09, Decision of inadmissibility of 2 July 2013.

Ferrari S., Benzo A. (eds.), Between Cultural Diversity and Common Heritage: Legal and Religious Perspectives on the Sacred Places of the Mediterranean, Routledge, London 2016.

Forrest C., International Law and the Protection of Cultural Heritage, Routledge, London 2011.

Gusten S., The Church that Politics Turned Into a Mosque, “The New York Times” , 8 February 2012, http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/09/world/middleeast/the-church-that-politics-turned-into-a-mosque.html [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Hagia Sophia – Church to Mosque…and Back?, “The Economist”, 10 May 2014, https://www.economist.com/news/europe/21601895-talk-haghia-sophia-once-again-becomingmosque-church-mosqueand-back [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Harmanasah R., Performing Social Forgetting in a Post-Conflict Landscape: The Case of Cyprus [Ph.D. diss.], University of Pittsburgh 2014.

Hayden R.M., Antagonistic Tolerance: Competitive Sharing of Religious Sites and Spaces, Routledge, London 2016.

Hayden R.M., Tanveri-Erdemir T., Erdemir A., The Iconostasis in the Republican Mosque: Transformed Religious Sites as Artefacts of Intersecting Religioscapes, “International Journal of Middle East Studies” 2014, Vol. 46(3).

International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, 16 December 1966, 999 UNTS 171.

Ktistakis Y., Turkey, paper presented at “Places of Worship and Holy Sites in Europe and the Middle East: Status and Protection under National and International Law” Conference, Cyprus, 8-10 November 2017.

The Role of Non-State Actors in the Cultural Heritage Field – The Case of the Orthodox Church and Its Heritage in Turkey Letsch C., Turkey: Mystery Surrounds Decision to Turn Byzantine Church Museum into a Mosque, “EurasiaNet”, 2 December 2011, http://www.eurasianet.org/print/64627 [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Lixinski L., Religious Cultural Heritage: The Law and Politics of Conservation, Iconoclasm and Identity, in: G. Hooper (ed.), Heritage at the Interface: Interpretation and Identity, University Press of Florida, Gainesville 2018.

Lostal M., International Cultural Heritage Law in Armed Conflict: Case-Studies of Syria, Libya, Mali, the Invasion of Iraq, and the Buddhas of Bamiyan, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2017.

Matthews O., Islamists and Secularists Battle Over Turkey’s Hagia Sophia Museum, “Newsweek”, 2 June 2015, http://www.newsweek.com/2015/06/12/battle-over-hagia-sophia-338091.html [accessed: 3.05.2019].

McGuckin J.A., The Orthodox Church: An Introduction to the History, Doctrine and Spiritual Culture, John Wiley & Sons, Chichester 2009.

Meron T., The Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict within the Case-law of the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, “Museum International” 2005, Vol. 57(4).

Mose G.M., The Destruction of Churches and Mosques in Bosnia-Herzegovina: Seeking a Rights-Based Approach to the Protection of Religious Cultural Property, “Buffalo Journal of International Law” 1997, Vol. 3.

Movesian M., Will the Hagia Sophia Again Become a Mosque?, “First Things”, 11 December 2013, https://www.firstthings.com/blogs/firstthoughts/2013/12/will-the-hagia-sophia-again-become-a-mosque [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Ninth Hagia Sophia Church Converted into a Mosque in Turkey, “Pravoslavie”, 25 September 2014, http://www.pravoslavie.ru/english/73914.htm [accessed: 3.05.2019].

No Halki Seminary Without Minarets on Athens Mosque, Erdogan Says, “Ekathimerini”, 18 February 2019, http://www.ekathimerini.com/237805/article/ekathimerini/news/no-halki-seminary-without-minarets-on-athens-mosque-erdogan-says [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Noortmann M., Reinisch A., Ryngaert C. (eds.), Non-State Actors in International Law, Hart Publishing, Oxford 2015.

Noortmann M., Ryngaert C. (eds.), Non-State Actor Dynamics in International Law. From Law-Takers to Law-Makers, Ashgate, Farnham 2010.

O’Keefe R., The Protection of Cultural Property in Armed Conflict, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2006.

Öktem E., Turkey, in: G. Robbers, W.C. Durham (eds.), Encyclopedia of Law and Religion, BrillOnline Reference Works, 5 December 2017.

Orser Jr C.E., Transnational Diaspora and Rights of Heritage in: H. Silverman, D.F. Ruggles (eds.), Cultural Heritage and Human Rights, Springer-Verlag, New York 2007.

Pontian Outrage as Turkey Cancels August 15 Church Service at Panagia Soumela, “Greek City Times”, 11 August 2016, https://greekcitytimes.com/2016/08/11/pontian-outrage-as-turkey-cancels-august-15-church-service-at-panayia-soumela [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Protocol No. 1 to the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, 20 March 1952, ETS 9.

Reinalda B. (ed.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Non-State Actors, Ashgate, Farnham 2011.

Resneck J., Hagia Sophia Mosque? Turkish Leaders Call for Conversion of Istanbul Landmark, Alarming Religious Minorities, “Huffington Post”, 4 December 2013, http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/12/04/hagia-sophia-mosque_n_4386401.html [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Singh R.P.B., The Contestation of Heritage: The Enduring Importance of Religion, in: B. Graham, P. Howard (eds.), The Ashgate Research Companion to Heritage and Identity, Ashgate, Farnham 2008.

Toktas S., Aras B., The EU and Minority Rights in Turkey, “Political Science Quarterly” 2010, Vol. 124(4).

Martínez-Torrón J., European Convention on Human Rights, in: G. Robbers (ed.), Encyclopedia of Law and Religion, BrillOnline Reference Works, 2015.

Treaty of Lausanne, 24 July 1923, 28 LNTS 701.

Universal Declaration of Human Rights, 10 December 1948, UNGA Res. 217 A(III).

Venice Commission and Office for Democratic Institutions and Human Rights, Guidelines on the Legal Personality of Religious or Belief Communities, 2015.

Vrdoljak A.F., Enforcement of Restitution of Cultural Heritage Through Peace Agreements, in: F. Francioni, J. Gordley (eds.), Enforcing International Cultural Heritage Law, Oxford University Press, Oxford 2013.

Vrdoljak A.F., Human Rights and Cultural Heritage in International Law, in: F. Lenzerini, A.F. Vrdoljak (eds.), International Law for Common Goods: Normative Perspectives on Human Rights, Culture and Nature, Hart Publishing, Oxford 2005.

Ware T., The Orthodox Church, rev. ed., Penguin Books, Harmondsworth 1985.

Zaman A., Another Byzantine Church Becomes Mosque in Turkey, “Al-Monitor”, 7 August 2013, http://www.al-monitor.com/pulse/originals/2013/08/another-byzantine-church-becomes-a-mosque.html [accessed: 3.05.2019].

Czasopismo ukazuje się w sposób ciągły on-line.

Pierwotną formą czasopisma jest wersja papierowa.