Looking Humanity in the Eye and Seeing its Loss in the Eyes of the ICC: An Evaluation of Daesh’s Destruction of Palmyra using the Gravity Assessment Made by the ICC Prosecutor in the Al Mahdi Case

Musab Talha Günay

Abstrakt

Under international law, cultural property is protected by a broad range of legal instruments prohibiting its destruction during armed conflicts. At the same time, the premise that international crimes must be of a sufficient gravity plays a crucial role in international criminal law. In this sense, the enforcement of the legislative framework aimed at the protection of cultural property before an international court is only possible if the crime concerned is sufficiently grave in the context of international criminal law. While the latest gravity assessment regarding such a crime was made by the International Criminal Court (ICC) Prosecutor in Al Mahdi case, previous examples include similar assessments made by the International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia for the shelling of Dubrovnik in the Jokić and Strugar cases. Recently, in addition to its humanitarian plight on a horrible scale, the Syrian Civil War has also seriously affected all six World Heritage Sites within its territory, including the Site of Palmyra. As a result of this ongoing armed conflict, the monuments in the Site of Palmyra experienced widespread damage inflicted by Daesh. Having reference to the ICC Prosecutor’s assessment of the gravity of the crime in the Al Mahdi case, this article analyses the legal arguments which  support the thesis that its destruction is clearly grave enough to take further action by the international community, even if not yet by the ICC due to its lack of jurisdiction.

Słowa kluczowe: protection of cultural property, gravity assessment, the Site of Palmyra, ICC Prosecutor, Al Mahdi case
References

Agha A.W., Issue 2: Syrian Armed Conflict, “Journal of East Asia and International Law” 2013, Vol. 6.

Appeals Chamber, Prosecutor v. Dusko Tadić, Case No. IT-94-1-T, Decision on the Defence Motion for Interlocutory Appeal on Jurisdiction of 2 October 1995.

Boylan P., Review of the Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, UNESCO Publishing, London 1993.

Caitlin V.H., Killing a Culture: The Intentional Destruction of Cultural Heritage in Iraq and Syria under International Law, “Georgia Journal of International & Comparative Law” 2016, Vol. 45.

Convention (II) with Respect to the Laws and Customs of War on Land and its annex: Regulations concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land, 29 July 1899, 32 Stat. 1803.

Convention (IV) respecting the Laws and Customs of War on Land and its annex: Regulations concerning the Laws and Customs of War on Land, 18 October 1907, 36 Stat. 2277.

Convention Concerning the Protection of the World Cultural and Natural Heritage, 16 November 1972, 1037 UNTS 151.

Convention for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, 7 August 1956, 249 UNTS 215.

Cunliffe E., Muhesen N., Lostal M., The Destruction of Cultural Property in the Syrian Conflict: Legal Implications and Obligations, “International Journal of Cultural Property” 2016, Vol. 23.

Dearden L., Isis Driven Out of Ancient Syrian City of Palmyra for Second Time, “The Guardian”, 2 March 2017, https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/middle-east/isis-palmyra-syria driven-out-second-time-islamic-state-ancient-roman-ruins-assad-executionsa7607351.html [accessed: 3.07.2019].

deGuzman M., How Serious are International Crimes? The Gravity Problem in International Criminal Law, “Columbia Journal of Transnational Law” 2012, Vol. 51.

Doppelhofer C., Will Palmyra Rise Again? – War Crimes against Cultural Heritage and Post-War Reconstruction, “UN Office of the High Commissioner”, 2016, https://www.ohchr.org/

Documents/Issues/CulturalRights/DestructionHeritage/NGOS/Ch.Doppelhofer.pdf [accessed: 5.07.2019].

El Zeidy M., The Gravity Threshold under the Statute of the International Criminal Court, “Criminal Law Forum” 2008, Vol. 19.

Ellis M., The ICC’s Role in Combatting the Destruction of Cultural Heritage, “Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law” 2017, Vol. 49.

Evans D., Syrian Army, with Russian Air Support, Advances Inside Palmyra, “Reuters UK”, 25 March 2016, https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-mideast-crisis-syria-idUKKCN-0WR0R8 [accessed: 3.07.2019].

Gerstenblith P., The Destruction of Cultural Heritage: A Crime Against Property or a Crime Against People?, “The John Marshall Review of Intellectual Property Law” 2016, Vol. 15.

Gill T.D., Classifying the Conflict in Syria, “International Law Studies (Naval War College)” 2016, Vol. 92.

Gottlieb Y., Criminalizing Destruction of Cultural Property: A Proposal for Defining New Crimes under the Rome Statute of the ICC, “Penn State International Law Review” 2005, Vol. 23.

Grotius H., Kelsey F.W., De Jure Belli Ac Pads Libri Tres, Clarendon Press, Oxford 1925.

Guy M., Readings of the Rwandan Genocide, “African Studies Review” 2002, Vol. 45.

Henckaerts J.M., New Rules for the Protection of Cultural Property in Armed Conflict, “International Review of the Red Cross” 1999, Vol. 81.

Henckaerts J.M., Doswald-Beck L., Customary International Humanitarian Law, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2005.

Hladik J., Protect Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, Program and Meeting Document, 2005, https://unesdoc.unesco.org/ark:/48223/pf0000138645 [accessed:25.11.2018].

Holliday J., The Struggle for Syria in 2011: An Operational and Regional Analysis, Institute for the Study of War, Washington 2011.

ICC, Case Information Sheet: The Prosecutor v. Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi, No. ICC-PIDS-CISMAL-01-08/16, 20 March 2018, https://www.icc-cpi.int/CaseInformationSheets/Al-MahdiEng.pdf [accessed: 1.12.2018].

ICC-OTP, Policy Paper on Case Selection and Prioritisation, 15 September 2016, https://www.icc-cpi.int/itemsDocuments/20160915_OTP-Policy_Case-Selection_Eng.pdf [accessed: 12.12.2018].

ICC-OTP, Policy Paper on Preliminary Examinations, 1 November 2013, https://www.icccpi.int/iccdocs/otp/OTP-Policy_Paper_Preliminary_Examinations_2013-ENG.pd [accessed: 13.11.2019].

ICC-OTP, Situation in Mali – Article 53(1) Report, 16 January 2013, https://www.icc-cpi.int/itemsDocuments/SASMaliArticle53_1PublicReportENG16Jan2013.pdf [accessed: 6.01.2019].

ICC-OTP, Situation on Registered Vessels of Comoros, Greece and Cambodia – Article 53(1) Report, 6 November 2014, https://www.icc-cpi.int/iccdocs/otp/OTP-COM-Article_53(1)-Report-06Nov2014Eng.pdf [accessed: 13.11.2019].

ISIL Blows up Arch of Triumph in Syria’s Palmyra, “Al Jazeera”, 5 October 2015, https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2015/10/isil-blows-arch-triumph-syria-palmyra-151005033238445.html [accessed: 1.07.2019].

ISIS Destroys Part of Roman Theater in Palmyra, “Reuters”, 20 January 2017, https://www.rt.com/news/374315-syria-palmyra-roman-theatre/ [accessed: 5.07.2019].

Isis Militants Destroy 2,000-year-old Statue of Lion at Palmyra, “The Guardian”, 2 July 2015, https://www.theguardian.com/world/2015/jul/02/isis-militants-destroy-palmyrastone-lion-al-lat [accessed: 13.07.2019].

Kaplan M., Palmyra Temple Destroyed: Islamic State Militants Blow up 2,000-year-old Baalshamin Temple in Ancient City, “IB Times”, 23 August 2015, http://www.ibtimes.com/palmyra-temple-destroyed-islamic-state-militants-blow-2000-year-old-baalshamintemple-2064786 [accessed: 10.07.2019].

Keane D., The Failure to Protect Cultural Property in Wartime, “DePaul Journal of Art, Technology and Intellectual Property Law” 2004, Vol. 14.

Kersten M., Big Fish or Little Fish – Who Should the International Criminal Court Target?, “Justicehub”, 31 August 2016, https://justicehub.org/article/big-fish-or-little-fish-whoshould-international-criminal-court-target [accessed: 6.01.2019].

Klamberg M., Commentary on the Law of the International Criminal Court, Torkel Opsahl Academic EPublisher, Brussels 2017.

Longobardo M., Factors Relevant for the Assessment of Sufficient Gravity in the ICC. Proceedings and the Elements of International Crimes, “Zoom-In Questions of International Law” 2016, Vol. 36.

Lostal M., The First of Its Kind: The ICC Opens a Case Against Ahmad Al Faqi Al Mahdi for the Destruction of Cultural Heritage in Mali, “Global Policy Forum”, 2 October 2015, https:// www.globalpolicy.org/home/163-general/52814-icc-opens-a-case-for-the-destruction-of-cultural-heritage-in-mali.html [accessed: 10.12.2018].

Mahnad P.L., Protecting Cultural Property in Syria: New Opportunities for States to Enhance Compliance with International Law, “International Review of the Red Cross” 2019, Vol. 99.

Massey D., A Place in the World? Places, Cultures and Globalization, Oxford University Press, New York 1995.

Murphy R., Gravity Issues and the International Criminal Court, “Criminal Law Forum” 2006, Vol. 17.

Noyes J., The Politics of Iconoclasm: Religion, Violence and the Culture of Image Breaking in Christianity and Islam, I.B. Tauris, London 2013.

O’Keefe R., The Protection of Cultural Property in Armed Conflict, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 2006.

Ochi M., Gravity Threshold Before the ICC, “International Crime Database Brief”, January 2016, http://www.internationalcrimesdatabase.org/upload/documents/20160111T115040-Ochi%20ICD%20Format.pdf [accessed: 5.11.2018].

Palmyra’s Baalshamin Temple Blown up by IS, “BBC News”, 9 September 2015, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-middle-east-34036644 [accessed: 12.07.2019].

Prosecutor v. Al Mahdi (Case No. ICC-01/12-01/15-171), Judgment of 27 September 2016.

Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of International Armed Conflicts (Protocol I), 7 December 1979, 1125 UNTS 3.

Protocol Additional to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, and relating to the Protection of Victims of Non-International Armed Conflicts (Protocol II), 7 December 1979, 1125 UNTS 609.

Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, 17 July 1998, 2187 UNTS 3.

Romey K., Why ISIS Hates Archaeology and Blew up Ancient Iraqi Palace, “National Geographic”, 14 April 2015, http://news.nationalgeographic.com/2015/04/150414-why-islamic-statedestroyed-assyrian-palace-nimrud-iraq-video-isis-isil-archaeology/[accessed: 10.07.2019].

SáCouto S., Cleary K., The Gravity Threshold of the International Criminal Court, “American Journal of International Law” 2008, Vol. 23.

Sandoz Y. et al., Commentary on the Additional Protocols of 8 June 1977 to the Geneva Conventions of 12 August 1949, International Committee of the Red Cross, Geneva 1987.

Second Protocol to the Hague Convention of 1954 for the Protection of Cultural Property in the Event of Armed Conflict, 9 March 2004, 2253 UNTS 172.

Smith L., Archaeological Theory and the Politics of Cultural Heritage, Routledge, London – New York 2004.

Statute of the International Tribunal for the Prosecution of Persons Responsible for Serious Violations of International Humanitarian Law Committed in the Territory of the Former Yugoslavia since 1991, 25 May 1993, 32 ILM 1159.

Trial Chamber I, Prosecutor v. Milan Martić, Case No. IT-95-11, Judgment of 12 June 2007.

Trial Chamber I, Prosecutor v. Miodrag Jokić, Case No. IT-01-42/1-S, Judgment of 18 March 2004.

Trial Chamber II, Prosecutor v. Pavle Strugar, Case No. IT-01-42-T, Judgment of 31 January 2005.

UN Department of Public Information, Security Council Press Statement on Destruction of Cultural Heritage, Executions in Palmyra, 20 January 2017, UN Doc. SC/12690, https://www.un.org/press/en/2017/sc12690.doc.htm [accessed: 27.06.2019].

UN Security Council, Security Council Resolution 808, No. S/RES/808, 22 February 1993.

UNESCO, Director-General Irina Bokova Firmly Condemns the Destruction of Palmyra’s Ancient Temple of Baalshamin, Syria, 1 September 2015, http://en.unesco.org/news/director-general-irina-bokova-firmly-condemns-destruction-palmyra-s-ancient-temple-baalshamin [accessed: 11.07.2019].

UNESCO, Records of the General Conference, UNESCO Doc. 32 C/Resolutions, 29 September – 17 October 2003, Vol. 1.

UNESCO, State of Conservation of the Properties Inscribed on the List of World Heritage in Danger, No. WHC/18/42.COM/7A.Add, 28 May 2018, https://whc.unesco.org/archive/ 2018/whc18-42com-7AAdd-en.pdf [accessed: 13.07.2019].

UNESCO, World Cultural Heritage List: Old City of Dubrovnik, https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/95 [accessed: 29.11.2018].

UNESCO, World Cultural Heritage List: Site of Palmyra, http://whc.unesco.org/en/list/23[accessed: 1.07.2019].

UNESCO, World Cultural Heritage List: Timbuktu, https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/119 [accessed: 5.01.2019].

UNESCO, World Heritage Committee Report – 37th Session, No. WCH13/37.COM/7B.Add, 17 May 2013, http://whc.unesco.org/archive/2013/wh13-37com-7B-Add-en.pdf [accessed: 10.07.2019].

Vreeland H., Hugo Grotius, the Father of the Modern Science of International Law, Oxford University Press, New York 1917.

Walasek H., The ICTY and the Prosecution of Crimes Against Cultural and Religious Property, “Ashgate”, 2015, https://perma.cc/PAC2-3L63 [accessed: 5.01.2019].

Wederman B., Ford D., Video Shows ISIS Militants Destroying Antiquities in Iraq, “CNN”, 27 February 2015, http://cnn.com/2015/02/26/middleeast/isis-antiquities-vandalism/ [accessed: 14.07.2019].

Westall S., Islamic State Destroys Part of Syria’s Temple of Bel, “Reuters UK”, 30 August 2015, https://uk.reuters.com/article/uk-mideast-crisis-syria-bel/islamic-state-destroys-part-of-syrias-temple-of-bel-monitors-idUKKCN0QZ0XO2015083 0 [accessed: 3.07.2019].

Wierczyńska K., Jakubowski A., Individual Responsibility for Deliberate Destruction of Cultural Heritage: Contextualizing the ICC Judgment in the Al-Mahdi Case, “Chinese Journal of International Law” 2017, Vol. 16.

Williams S.E., Isil Retakes Historic City of Palmyra, “The Telegraph”, 11 December 2016, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/12/10/islamic-state-back-unesco-world-heritage-city-palmyra-surprise/ [accessed: 4.07.2019].

Czasopismo ukazuje się w sposób ciągły on-line.

Pierwotną formą czasopisma jest wersja papierowa.