Priorities, factors and alternatives involved in the choice of medical specialty – an empirical study on year sixth medical students

Agnieszka Pawełczyk,

Wiktor Adamus,

Maciej Radek,

Tomasz Pawełczyk

Abstrakt

Phenomenon. The process of career decision making by medical students has been the subject of many studies analyzing the choice. However, the studies have not analyzed determination of global priorities for the criteria of choice or alternatives regarding the choice of medical specialty. The goal of this paper is to determine the weights (priorities), factors and alternatives involved in the choice of specialty for year six medical students.

Approach. A sample of 202 final-year medical students at the Medical University was examined using Saaty’s Analytic Hierarchy Process. During interviews, the students used the Saaty’s scale to pair various factors influencing their choice of medical specialty. Analysis was performed to evaluate the crucial decisive criteria and various decisive models.

Findings. When choosing the medical specialty, the highest rank was given to “individual physician’s aptitude and expected professional attainment” (P = 0.4748), followed by “the features of the medical specialty” (P = 0.3636) and “the process of training for the specialty” (P = 0.1616). The most important sub-criteria were “intellectual qualities and competencies useful in practicing the specialty”, “place of work” and “opportunity to create one’s own medical practice”. A model of specialty choice was obtained. The most important criteria of choice were “opportunities for professional career in healthcare entities”, “place of work”, “opportunity to create one’s own medical practice” and “expected income”. 

Insights. Understanding the factors influencing choice of specialty enables workforce planning to meet local and national healthcare needs. It also helps optimize the profile of medical education courses offered by medical universities. The results obtained, although limited in their generalisability, may support organizing specific curricula and strategies to encourage the choice of specialties in short supply. 

Przygotowanie do wydania elektronicznego finansowane w ramach umowy 637/P-DUN/2019 ze środków Ministerstwa Nauki i Szkolnictwa Wyższego przeznaczonych na działalność upowszechniającą naukę.

Słowa kluczowe: Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP), alternatives, decision making, medical specialty, medical students, priorities / proces decyzyjny, problem decyzyjny, specjalności medyczne, studenci medycyny
References

1. Kamalakanthan A.,  Jackson  S.,  The  Supply  of  Doctors in Australia: Is There A Shortage?, 2006; http://www.uq.edu. au/economics/abstract/341.pdf (accessed: 14.02.2018).

2. Fazel S., E.K, Specialty choice in UK junior doctors: Is psychiatry the least popular specialty for UK and international  medical graduates?, “BMC Medical Education” 2009; 77 (9).

3. Forcier M.B., Simoens S., Giuffrida A., Impact, regulation and health policy implications of physician migration in OECD countries, “Human Resources for Health” 2004; 2 (1): 12.

4. Vujicic M. et al., The role of wages in the migration of health care professionals from developing countries, “Human Resources for Health” 2004; 2 (1): 3.

5. McAlister R.P. et al., Attrition in residents entering US obstetrics and gynecology residencies: analysis of National GME  Census data, “American Journal of Obstetrics and Gynecology” 2008; 199 (5): 574 e1‒576e1.

6. Longo W.E. et al., Attrition of categoric general surgery residents: results of a 20-year audit, “American Journal of Surgery” 2009; 197 (6): 774‒778; discussion 779‒780.

7. Riebschleger M. et al., Noncompletion in pediatric rheumatology fellowships, “Journal of Graduate Medical Education” 2014; 6 (1): 158‒161.

8. Goldenberg M.N., Williams D.K., Spollen J.J., Stability of and  factors  related  to  medical  student  specialty  choice of psychiatry, “Am. J. Psychiatry 2017; 174 (9): 859‒866.

9. Pawelczyk A.M. et al., Temperament traits and preference for surgical or nonsurgical specialties in year 6 medical students,  Teaching and Learning in Medicine” 2014; 26 (4): 387‒392.

10. Soethout M., Heymans M., TenCate O., Career preference and medical students biographical characteristics and academic achievement, “Medical Teacher 2008; 30: e15‒e30.

11. Fadem B.H. et al., Predicting medical specialty choice: A model based on students’ records, “Journal of Medcial Education” 1984; 59 (5): 407‒415.

12. Gorenflo D.W., Ruffin M.T.t., Sheets K.J., A multivariate model for specialty preference by medical students, “Journal of Family Practice” 1994; 39 (6): 570‒576.

13. Reed V.A., Jernstedt G.C., Reber E.S., Understanding and improving medical student specialty choice: A synthesis of the literature using decision theory as a referent, Teaching and Learning in Medicine” 2001; 13 (2): 117‒129.

14. Smith V., Bethune C., Hurley K.F., Examining medical student specialty choice through a gender lens: An orientational qualitative study, Teach Learn. Med.” 2018; 30 (1): 33‒44.

15. McGreevy J., Wiebe D., A preliminary measurement of the surgical personality, “American Journal of Surgery” 2002; 184 (2): 121‒125.

16. Moore S., Katz B., Holder J., Machiavellianism and medical career choices, “Psychological Reports 1995; 76 (3 Pt 1): 803‒807.

17. Kwon O.Y., Park S.Y., Specialty choice preference of medical students according to personality traits by Five-Factor Model, “Korean J. Med. Educ.” 2016; 28 (1): 95‒102.

18. Murdoch M.M. et al., Evaluating the psychometric properties of a scale to measure medical students’ career-related values, “Academic Medicine” 2001; 76 (2): 157‒165.

19. Schwartz M.D. et al., Medical student interest in internal medicine. Initial report of the Society of General Internal Medicine Interest Group Survey on Factors Influencing Career Choice in Internal Medicine, “Annals of Internal Medicine” 1991; 114 (1): 6‒15.

20. Gotz K. et al., [Aspirations of medical students: “planning for a secure career” results of an online-survey among students at five medical schools in Germany], “Deutsche medizinische Wochenschrift” 2011; 136 (6): 253‒257.

21. Li J., Plastic surgery or primary care? Altruistic preferences and expected specialty choice of U.S. medical students, “J. Health Econ.” 2018; 62: 45‒59.

22. Azizzadeh A.  et  al.,  Factors  influencing career  choice among  medical students interested in surgery, “Current Surgery” 2003; 60 (2): 210‒213.

23. Kiker B.F., Zeh M., Relative income expectations, expected malpractice premium costs, and other determinants of physician specialty choice, “Journal of Health and Social Behavior” 1998; 39 (2): 152‒167.

24. Hatem Mahmoud Shaheen Alahwal et al., Career counseling activities and choice of specialties among medical interns, “Bahrain Medical Bulletin” 2010; 32 (4).

25. Rehman A. et al., Pakistani medical students specialty preference and the influencing factors, “JPMA. The Journal of the Pakistan Medical Association 2011; 61 (7): 713‒718.

26. Alers M. et al., Speciality preferences in Dutch medical students influenced by their anticipation on family responsibilities, “Perspectives  on  Medical  Education” 2014;  3 (6): 443‒454.

27. DeWitt D.E., Curtis J.R., Burke W., What influences career choices among graduates of a primary care training program?,  “Journal of General Internal Medicine” 1998; 13 (4): 257‒261.

28. Cleland J.A. et al., A survey of factors influencing career preference in  new-entrant and  exiting medical students from four UK medical schools, “BMC Medical Education” 2014; 14: 151.

29. Grigg M., Arora M., Diwan A., Australian medical students and their choice of surgery as a career: A review, “Australian and New Zeland Journal of Surgery” 2014; 84 (9): 653‒655.

30. Kim  Y.Y.  et  al.,  Factors  associated  with  the  specialty choice of Korean medical students: A cross-sectional survey, “Hum. Resour. Health” 2016; 14 (1): 45.

31. Gong B. et al., Influence of artificial intelligence on Canadian medical students preference for radiology specialty: A National Survey Study, “Acad. Radiol. 2019; 26 (4): 566‒577.

32. Osborn H.A. et al., Primary care specialty career choice among Canadian medical students: Understanding the factors that influence their decisions, “Can. Fam. Physician” 2017; 63 (2): e107‒e113.

33. Kopacz D.R., Grossman L.S., Klamen D.L., Medical students and AIDS: Knowledge, attitudes and implications for education, “Health Education Research” 1999; 14 (1): 1‒6.

34. Newton D.A., Grayson M.S., Whitley T.W., What predicts medical student career choice?, “Journal of General Internal Medicine” 1998; 13 (3): 200‒203.

35. Bonura E.M., Armstrong W.S., Increasing subspecialization in the field of infectious diseases: Evaluating challenges and strategies to move forward, “J. Infect. Dis.” 2017; 216 (suppl. 5): S594‒S599.

36. Lepiece B. et al., Social dominance theory and medical specialty choice, “Advances in Health Sciences Education: Theory and Practice” 2015.

37. Ibrahim M. et al., What factors influence British medical students’ career intentions?, “Medical Teacher” 2014; 36 (12): 1064‒1072.

38. Creed P.A., Searle J., Rogers M.E., Medical specialty prestige and lifestyle preferences for medical students, “Social Science and Medicine” 2010; 71 (6): 1084‒1088.

39. Takeda Y. et al., Characteristic profiles among students and junior doctors with specific career preferences, “BMC Medical Education” 2013; 13 (Sep 12).

40. Valentino J., Blue A.V., Donnelly M.B., The most valuable critical incidents in a 4th-year acting internship in surgery, Teaching and Learning in Medicine” 1999; 11: 75–79.

41. Chang P.Y. et al., Factors influencing medical students’ choice of specialty, “J. Formos. Med. Assoc.” 2006; 105 (6): 489‒496.

42. Wang K.I. et al., Analysis of senior medical students’ preferences in specialty choice a survey in a medical school in northern Taiwan, “Chang Gung Medical Journal” 2007; 30 (4): 339‒353.

43. Adamus W., F.J. W., The evolution of shale gas development and energy security in Poland: Presenting a hierarchical choice of priorities, “Energy Research & Social Science” 2016; 20: 168‒178.

44. Adamus  W.,  Gręda  A.,  Multi-criteria  decision  support in solving the problems of organization and management, “Operations Research and Decisions” 2005; 2: 5‒37.

45. Adamus W., Łasak P., Application of AHP to choose the lo cation of surveillance of the financial market, “Bank and Credit” 2010; 41 (4): 73‒101.

46. Wolfslehner B., Vacik H., Lexer M., Application of the analytic network process in multi-criteria analysis of sustainable forest  management, “Forest  Ecology  and  Management” 2005; 207: 165‒166.

47. Adamus W., Adamus T., [Rating hospitals from the perspective of patients]. Article in Polish, “Zeszyty Naukowe Ochrony  Zdrowia. Zdrowie Publiczne i Zarządzanie” 2012; 10 (4): 4‒18.

48. Liberatore M.J., Nydick R.L., The analytic hierarchy process in medical and health care decision making: A literature review,  “European Journal of Operational Research” 2008; 189 (1): 194‒207.

49. Chang P.Y. et al., Factors influencing medical students’ choice of specialt, “Journal of the Formosan Medical Association” 2006; 105 (6): 489‒496.

50. Saaty T.L., Decision Making for Leaders. The Analytic Hierarchy Process for Decisions in a Complex World, RWS Publications, Pittsburgh, PA 2001.

51. Saaty T.L., The Analytic Hierarchy Process: Planning, Priority Setting, Resource Allocation, McGraw-Hill International Book Co., New York‒London 1980: xiii, 287.

52. Byun D.H., The AHP approach for selecting an automobile purchase model, “Information and Management” 2001; 38: 289–297.

53. Hafeez K., Zhang Y., Malak N., Determining key capabilities of a firm using analytic hierarchy proces, “International Journal of Production Economics” 2002; 76: 39–51.

54. Bitran M. et al., [Influence of personality and learning styles in the choice of medical specialty], “Revista Medica de Chile” 2005; 133 (10): 1191‒1199.

Czasopismo ukazuje się w sposób ciągły on-line.
Pierwotną wersją czasopisma jest wersja elektroniczna.