Remarks on Aristotle’s Thettalon politeia

Sławomir Sprawski

Abstrakt

This article attempts to make a critical assessment of the preserved fragments of Thettalon politeia as a source on the history of early Thessaly. The traces of the existence of this text come from the second half of the 2nd century CE at the earliest, but even then it was seen as one of the Politeiai recorded by Aristotle. As a result of this attribution, information from this text is treated as a reliable source of knowledge on the koinon organization of the Thessalians and their joint army. There are, however, important reasons to treat this source with the greatest caution: we have only six short quotations from the work available, and the part which refers to Aleuas’ supposed reforms is very much damaged and has been subjected to a number of emendations by its various publishers. The description of the system of mobilization of the Thessalian army from Thettalon politeia seems anachronistic, and probably arose under the influence of information about the reorganization of the army conducted in the 370s BCE by Jason of Pherae and the propaganda that accompanied these changes.

Słowa kluczowe: Aristotle, Thettalon politeia, Thessaly, Aleuas the Red, Jason of Pherae
References
  • Best, J. (1969): Thracian Peltasts and their Infl uence on Greek Warfare, Groningen.
  • Bloch, H. (1940): Heraklides Lembos and his Epitome of Aristotle’s Politeiai, TPAPhA 71: 27–39.
  • Daintree, D. (1990): The Virgil Commentary of Aelius Donatus – Balsk Hole or “Eminence Grise”?, Greece & Rome 37: 65–79.
  • Decourt, J.-C., Nielsen, Th.H., Helly, B. et al. (2004): Thessalia and Adjacent Regions, in: M.H. Hansen, Th.H. Nielsen (eds.), An Inventory of Archaic and Classical Poleis, Oxford: 676–731.
  • Dickey, E. (2007): Ancient Greek Scholarship. A Guide to Finding, Reading, and Understanding Scholia, Commentaries, Lexica and Grammatical
  • Treatises, from their Beginnings to the Byzantine Period, London–New York.
  • Hansen, M.H. (1997): Polis as the Generic Term for the State, in: Th.H. Nielsen (ed.), Yet More Studies in the Ancient Greek Polis, (Historia Einzelschriften 117), Stuttgart: 9–15.
  • Helly, B. (1995): L’État thessalien. Aleuas le Roux, les tétrades et les Tagoi, Lyon.
  • Hiller von Gaertringen, F. (1890): Das Königtum bei den Thessalern, in: Aus der Anomia, Archaeologische Beitrage, Berlin: 1–16.
  • Hose, M. (2002): Aristoteles. Die historischen Fragmente. Übersetzt und erläutert von Martin Hose, Berlin.
  • Jorodvic, I. (2008): Critias and Democracy, Balcanica 39: 33–46.
  • Keaney, J.J. (1963): Two Notes on the Tradition of Aristotle’s Writings, AJP 84: 52–63.
  • Larsen, J.A.O. (1960): A New Interpretation of the Thessalian Confederacy, CPh 55: 229–247.
  • Larsen, J.A.O. (1968): Greek Federal States, Oxford.
  • Lindsay, H. (1997): Strabo on Apellicon’s Library, RhM 140: 290–298.
  • Meyer, E. (1909): Theopompos Hellenika, Halle.
  • Preller, L. (1848): Zu Aristoteles politie der Thessaler, Philologus 3: 138–140.
  • Rhodes, P.J. (1981): A Conmentory on the Aristotelian Athenaion Politeia, Oxford.
  • Rey, F.E. (2008): Ciudadanos, Campesinos y Soldados. El Nacimiento de La Polis Griega y La Teoria de La Revolucion Hoplita (Anejos de Gladius), Madrid.
  • Sordi, M. (1958): La lega tessala fi ne ad Alessandro Magno, Roma.
  • Sprawski, S. (1999): Jason of Pherae, (Electrum 3), Kraków.
  • Sprawski, S. (2008): Aristotle on the History of Euboea? Remarks on the Author of Peri Euboias (FGrH 423), Journal of Classical Studies Matica Srpska 10: 107–116.
  • Toye, D.L. (1999): Aristotle’s Other Politeiai. Was the Athenaion Politeia Atypical?, CJ 94: 235–253.
  • Trevett, J. (1999): rev. Helly B., L’État thessalien. Aleuas le Roux, les tétrades et les Tagoi, JHS 119: 213.
  • Wade-Gery, H.T. (1924): Jason of Pherae and Aleuas the Red, JHS 44: 55–64.
  • Van Wees, H. (2000): The Development of the Hoplite Phalanx. Iconography and reality in the seventh century, in: H. Van Wees, War and Violence in Ancient Greece, London: 125–166.
  • Zecchini, G. (2000): Harpocration and Athenaeus Historographical Realtionship, in: D. Braund,
  • J. Wilkins (eds.), Athenaeus and His World. Reading Greek Culture in the Roman Empire, Exeter: 153–160.

Czasopismo ukazuje się w sposób ciągły on-line.
Pierwotną formą czasopisma jest wersja elektroniczna.