An Analysis of Chinese Ecomuseums in Relation to Ecomuseum Theories and Principles

Nunzia Borrelli,

Rongling Ge

Abstrakt

The main aim of this article is to reflect on the status of ecomuseums in China. There have been both ecomuseums and discourse about them for many years in China. However, despite the existence of academic literature on ecomuseums and therefore to the general theory of ecomuseums, from some points of view Chinese ecomuseums do not seem to be aligned with general ecomuseum principles. This article reflects both on how well ecomuseums in China fit the ecomuseum characteristics defined by the theory and, ultimately, on what we can learn from the Chinese experience. Our discussion is developed on the basis of both the existing academic literature and interviews conducted by the authors.

Słowa kluczowe: Ecomuseum, place, community, China
References

Bennett T., Civic laboratories: museums, cultural objecthood and the governance of the social in: Cultural studies 19, 5/2005, pp. 521–547.

Benoist L., Musées et muséologie, PUF, Paris 1971.

Borrelli N. & Davis P., How culture shapes nature: Reflections on ecomuseum practices in: Nature and Culture 7, 1/2012, pp. 31–47.

Bourdieu P. & Wacquant L. J., Réponses: pour une anthropologie réflexive, Seuil, Paris 1992.

Buttimer A. & Seamon D., The human experience of space and place. London: Croom Helm in: Transactions, Institute of British Geographers NS 18, 1980, pp. 460–480.

Cars G. & al., Urban governance, institutional capacity and social milieu, Routledge, London 2017.

Chio J., A landscape of travel. The work of tourism in rural ethnic China, University of Washington Press, Washington 2014.

Coaffee J. & Healey P., ‘My voice: My place’: Tracking transformations in urban governance in: Urban studies 40, 10/2003, pp. 1979–1999.

Corsane  G.,  From  ‘outreach’  to  inreach’:  How  ecomuseum  principles encourage community participation in museum processes in: Communication and exploration: Guiyang, China, (eds.) Su Dongai & J. Zhang, Zijin City Publishing House, Beijing 2005, pp. 109–124.

Corsane G., Using ecomuseum indicators to evaluate the Robben Island Museum and World Heritage Site in: Landscape Research 31, 4/2006, pp. 399–418.

Corsane G. & al., Ecomuseum Evaluation: Experiences in Piemonte and Liguria, Italy in: International Journal of Heritage Studies 13, 2/2007, pp. 101–116.

Corsane G. & al., Ecomuseum Performance in Piemonte and Liguria, Italy: The Significance of Capital in: International Journal of Heritage Studies 13, 3/2007, pp. 224–239.

Corsane G. & Holleman W., Ecomuseums: A Brief Evaluation in: Museums and the Environment, (ed.) R. de Jong, South African Museums Association, Pretoria 1993, pp. 111–125.

Davis P., Ecomuseums: A Sense of Place, Leicester University Press, London 1999.

Davis P., New Museologies and the Ecomuseum in: Research Companion to Heritage and Identity, (eds.) B. Graham & P. Howard, Ashgate, London 2008, pp. 397–414.

Davis P., Ecomuseums: A Sense of Place, [2nd ed.] A&C Black, London 2011. GCI (Getty Conservation Institute), China Principles (1997–2015): Application of the China Principles at Maogao Grottoes, Los Angeles, page updated on August 2019 [available at http://www.getty.edu/conservation/our_projects/field_projects/china/app_mogao.html, retrieved Oct. 2, 2019].

Goulding C., The commodification of the past, postmodern pastiche, and the search for authentic experiences at contemporary heritage attractions in: European Journal of Marketing 34, 7/2000, pp. 835–853.

Graburn N. & Jin L., Tourism and Museums in China in: Asian Journal of Tourism Research 2, 1/2017, pp. 1–34.

Hahn T., Olsson P., Folke C., & Johansson K., Trust–building, knowledge generation and organizational innovations: the role of a bridging organization for adaptive comanagement of a wetland landscape around Kristianstad, Sweden in: Human ecology 34, 4/2006, pp. 573–592.

Hamrin O. & Mats H., The Ecomuseum Bergslagen Falun: Ekomuseum Bergslagen in: Nordisk Museologi 2, 1996, pp. 27–34.

Hillier J. & Rooksby E. (eds.), Habitus: A sense of place, Ashgate, London 2005.

Hu C., Ecomuseums in Guizhou: Practice and Exploration in: Communication and Exploration: International Forum of Ecomuseums 9, 2005, pp. 15–18.

Hu C., Liuzhi Yuanze yu Minzu Wenhua Baohu [Liuzhi Principle and the Protection of Ethnic Culture] in: Zhongguo Wenwu Bao [Chinese Cultural Relics News] (2005–01–21), 2005, p. 5.

Hubert F., Ecomuseums in France: Contradictions and Distortions in: Chinese Museum 37, 1986, pp. 78–82.

Hudson K., Museums of Influence, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge 1987.

Hudson K., The Dream and the Reality in: Museums Journal 92, 4/1992, pp. 27–31.

Hudson K., Ecomuseums Become More Realistic in: Nordisk Museologi 7, 2/1996, pp. 11–20.

ICOMOS China, Zhongguo Wenwu Guji Baohu Zhunze [Principles for the Conservation of Heritage Sites in China], The Getty Conservation Institute, Los   Angele 2002   [availabl a http://www.getty.edu/conservation.publications_resources/pdf_publications/pdf/china_prin_heritage_sites.pdf, retrieved Oct. 1, 2019].

McCall V. & Gray C., Museums and the ‘new museology’: theory, practice and organisational  change  in:  Museum  Management  and  Curatorship  29, 1/2014, pp. 19–35.

Mensch van P., Towards a methodology of museology, University of Zagreb, Zagreb 1992.

Navaja O.,   Ne Common   Perspective for   Ecomuseums Community Museums,   and  Cultural  Landscape in:  Ecomuseum and   cultural landscapes. State of the art, (ed.) R. Riva, Studi e progetti, Milano 2017.

Newton J. & Franklin A., Delivering sustainable communities in China: using a  sustainable  livelihoods  framework  for  reviewing  the  promotion  of ecotourism in Anji in: Local Environment 16, 8/2011, pp. 789–806.

Nguyen T. H. H. & Cheung C., Authenticity and commodification of Hong Kong heritage tourism in: Proceedings of Invtur 2017 Conference. Co–creating the future of tourism, University of Aveiro Press, Aveiro 2017 [available at https://core.ac.uk/download/pdf/154425375.pdf, retrieved Oct. 10, 2019].

Nitzky W., Mediating Heritage Preservation and Rural Development: Ecomuseum Development in China in: Urban Anthropology 41, 2–3–4/2012, pp. 367–417.

Nitzky W., Ecomuseums with Chinese Characteristics: The Politics of Safe-  guarding  Living  Heritage in: Proceedings  of  Ecomuseums  2012  –  1st International  Conference  on  Ecomuseums,  Community  Museums  and

Living Communities, (eds.) S. Lira, R. Amoêda, C. Pinheiro, P. Davis, M. Stefano & G. Corsane, Green Lines Institute for Sustainable Development, Barcelos 2012, pp. 259–270.

Nitzky  W.,  Community  Empowerment  at  the  Periphery?  Participatory Approaches  to  Heritage  Protection  in  Guizhou,  China  in:  Cultural Heritage Politics in  China, (eds.) T.  R Blumenfield & H. Silverman, Springer, New York 2013, pp. 205–234.

Olsson P., Folke C., Galaz V., Hahn T., & Schultz L., Enhancing the fit through adaptive co–management: creating and maintaining bridging functions for matching scales in the Kristianstads Vattenrike Biosphere Reserve, Sweden in:  Ecology and Society 12,  1/2007  [available  at  https://www.ecology andsociety.org/vol12/iss1/art28/, retrieved Oct. 10, 2019].

Pan S., Shengtai Bowuguan ji qi zai Zhongguo de Fazhan: Lishi xing Guancha y Sikao   [Ecomuseum   and   It Development   i China:   Chronicle Observation and Perspectives] in: Chinese Museum Z1, 2011, pp. 24–33.

Pan S., Di San Dai Shengtai Bowuguan yu Anji Shengtai Bowuguan Qun Jianshe de Lilun Sikao [Theoretical Discussion on the Third–Generation Ecomuseums  and  the  Construction  of  Anji  Ecomuseum  Cluster]  in: Southeast Culture 236, 2013, pp. 86–93.

Pan S., Selfcognition and Selfeducation at Ecomuseum: From ‘Information Center to ‘Cognition Center in: Science Education and Museums 1, 2015, pp. 35–38.

Plummer R., Armitage D., & de L R., Adaptive comanagement and its relationship to environmental governance in: Ecology and Society 18, 1/2013 [available at https://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol18/iss1/art21/, retrieved Oct. 5, 2019].

Primo  J.,  Museus  Locais  e  Ecomuseologia:  Estudos  do  Projeto  para  o Ecomuseu da Murtosa in: Cadernos de Museologia 30, 2008 [available at https://revistas.ulusofona.pt/index.php/cadernosociomuseologia/issue/vie w/47, retrieved 10.10.2019].

Rivard R., Opening up the Museum or Toward a New Museology: Ecomuseums and  Open”  Museums,  Québec  1984  [copy  of  manuscrit  held  at  the Documentation Centre, Direction des Musées, Paris].

Rivard R., Museums and ecomuseums: questions and answers in: Økomu- seumsboka–Identitet, Økologi, Deltakelse, (eds.) J. Gjestrum & R. Maure, Norsk ICOM, Tromsø 1988, pp. 123–128.

Rivière G. H., The Ecomuseum: An Evolutive Definition in: Museum Interna- tional 37, 4/1985, pp. 182–184 [Chinese text transl. by Meng Qing–long].

Schultz L., Folke C., & Olsson P., Enhancing ecosystem management through socialecological  inventories:  lessons  from  Kristianstads  Vattenrike, Sweden in: Environmental Conservation 34, 2/2007, pp.140–152.

Shepherd R., Commodification, culture and tourism in: Tourist Studies 2, 2002, pp. 183–201.

Sofield T. H. B. & Li F. M., Tourism Development and Cultural Policies in China in: Annals of Tourism Research 25, 2/1998, pp. 362–392.

Su D., Zhongguo Shengtai Bowuguan de Daolu [Chinese Ecomuseum: The Path of Development] in: Chinese Museum 22, 3/2005, pp. 14–16.

Stead D. & Meijers E., Spatial Planning and Policy Integration: Concepts, Facilitators and Inhibitors in: Planning Theory & Practice 10, 3/2009, pp. 317–332.

Tuan Y.–F., Space and Place the Perspective of Experience, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis 1977.

UNWTO, UNWTO and China Organize First World Conference on Tourism for Development, Beijing 2016 [available at http://media.unwto.org/pressrelease/2016–02–24/unwto–and–china–organize–firstworld–conferencetourism–development, retrieved Oct. 1, 2019].

Varine de H., Ecomuseum: The word and beyond in: Chinese Museum 37, 1986, pp. 76–77.

Varine de H., Rethinking the museum concept in: Økomuseumsboka identitet, økologi, deltakelse, (eds.) J. A. Gjestrum & M. Maure, ICOM, Tromsø 1988, pp. 33–40.

Vergo P., The New museology, Reaktion Books, London 1989.

Westley F., Tjornbo O., Schultz L., Olsson P., Folke C., Crona B. & Bodin Ö., A theory of transformative agency in linked socialecological systems in: Ecology  and  Society  18,  3/2013  [available  at  https://www.ecologyandsociety.org/vol18/iss3/art27/, retrieved Oct. 5, 2019].

Wu  W.,  Cong  Minzu  Shengtai  Bowuguan  Kan  Guangxi  Minzu  Shengtai Wenhua de Baohu yu Chuancheng [The Protecting and Passing of Ethnic Cultural Resources in Guangxi] in: Guangxi Minzu Yanjiu [Guangxi Minzu Studies] 88, 2/2007, pp. 199–205.