GRAMMATICALIZATION PATHS AND CHAOS: DETERMINISM AND UNPREDICTABILITY OF THE SEMANTIC DEVELOPMENT OF VERBAL CONSTRUCTIONS (PART 3 – CHAOS IN GRAMMATICALIZATION)

Alexander Andrason

Abstrakt

This paper demonstrates that by applying Chaos Theory to the modelling of the evolution of verbal forms and verbal systems, it is possible to view classical grammaticalization paths as universal, and align this deterministic assumption with the unpredictability of concrete grammatical developments. The author argues that such an explanation is possible because traditional grammaticalization paths do not represent realistic cases of grammatical evolutions, but rather correspond to abstract and non-realistic deterministic laws which codify the order of the incorporation of new meanings to the semantic potential of a gram. Therefore, from a synchronic perspective, they can be used to represent the semantic potential of a form as a map or a state. In contrast, a realistic development emerges as a trajectory connecting such maps or states. Consequently, the cross-linguistic typological model of realistic evolutionary processes of a certain type corresponds to a state-space – it is a cluster of all possible trajectories the grams of a certain class can travel. This article – the last of the series – will formulate a chaotic model of the realistic evolution of verbal grams.

Słowa kluczowe: grammaticalization paths, verbal semantics, Chaos Theory, Cognitive Linguistics, semantic maps
References

Aikhenvald A. 2004. Evidentiality. Oxford.
Andrason A. 2011a. The Biblical Hebrew verbal system in light of grammaticalization – the second generation. – Hebrew Studies 52: 19–53.
Andrason A. 2011b. The Biblical Hebrew Wayyiqtol – a dynamic definition. – Journal of Hebrew Scriptures 11.7: 1–50.
Andrason A. 2012. Thermodynamic model of the Biblical Hebrew verbal system. – Eades D. (ed.). Grammaticalisation in Semitic. Journal of Semitic Studies Supplement Series 29. Oxford: 146–163.
Andrason A. 2013a. El sistema verbal hebreo en su contexto semítico: una visión dinámica. Estella.
Andrason A. 2013b. The map of the meaning of the be riŋ formation in Basse Mandinka. – Journal of West African Languages 40.2: 101–133.
Andrason A. 2014a. Qotel and its dynamics. [Part 2]. – Folia Orientalia 51: 139–153.
Andrason A. 2014b. From resultatives to present tenses: Simultaneous path of resultative formations. – Italian Journal of Linguistics 26: 1–58.
Andrason A. 2016a. A complex system of complex predicates: Tense, taxis, aspect and mood in Basse Mandinka from a grammaticalization and cognitive perspective. [PhD Diss., University of Stellenbosch].
Andrason A., Visser M. 2015. Affordances perspective and grammaticalization – incorporation of language, environment and users in the model of semantic paths. – Studies in Second Language Learning and Teaching 5.4: 663–698.
Andrason A. 2016b. From vectors to waves and streams. Semantic maps – a new generation. – Stellenbosch Papers in Linguistics 45: 1–29.
Andrason A., Locatell C. 2016. The perfect wave. – Biblical and Ancient Greek Linguistics 5: 7–121.
Auyang S. 1998a. How science comprehends chaos. [Paper presented at the Department of the History of Science Harvard University. February 23, 1998; www.creatingtechnology.org/essays/chaos.htm].
Auyang S. 1998b. Foundations of complex-system theories. Cambridge.
Auyang S. 2000. Mind in everyday life and cognitive science. Cambridge.
Birkmann T. 1987. Präteritopräsentia. Tübingen.
Bishop R. 2011. Metaphysical and epistemological issues in complex systems. – Hooker C. (ed.). Philosophy of complex systems. Amsterdam: 105–136.
Bybee J., Perkins R., Pagliuca W. 1994. The evolution of grammar. Chicago.
Bybee J. 2010. Language, usage and cognition. Cambridge.
Cilliers P. et al. 2013. Complexity, modeling, and natural resource management. – Ecology and Society 18.3: 1–12.
Dahl Ö. 2000a. The tense and aspect systems of European languages in a typological perspective. – Dahl Ö. (ed.). Tense and aspect in the languages of Europe. Berlin: 3–25.
Dahl Ö. (ed.). 2000b. Tense and aspect in the languages of Europe. Berlin.
Devaney R. 1989. An introduction to chaotic dynamical systems. Redwood City.
Evans V., Green M. 2006. Cognitive Linguistics: An introduction. Edinburgh.
Fischer K. 2010. Quantitative methods in cognitive semantics. Introduction to the volume. – Glyn D., Fischer K. (eds.). Quantiative methods in cognitive semantics: Corpus-driven approaches. Berlin: 43–59.
Geeraerts D. 2010. Theories of lexical semantics. Oxford.
Gilquin G. 2006. The place of prototypicality in corpus linguistics. – Gries S., Stefanowitsch A. (eds.). Corpora in Cognitive Linguistics. Berlin: 159–191.
Glyn D. 2010. Corpus-driven cognitive semantics introduction to the field. – Glyn D., Fischer K. (eds.). Quantiativem methods in cognitive semantics: Corpus-driven approaches. Berlin: 1–41.
Grevisse M. 1975. Le bon usage. [10th edition]. Gembloux.
Gries S. 2006. Corpus-based methods and cognitive semantics. – Gries S., Stefanowitsch A. (eds.). Corpora in Cognitive Linguistics. Berlin: 57–99.
Gries S., Divjak D. 2010. Quantitative approaches in usage-based cognitive semantics: Myths, erroneous assumptions, and a proposal. – Glyn D., Fischer K. (eds.). Quantiative methods in cognitive semantics: Corpus-driven approaches. Berlin: 333–353.
Gries S., Stefanowitsch A. (eds.). 2006. Corpora in Cognitive Linguistics. Berlin.
Kretzschmar W. 2015. Language and complex system. Cambridge.
Larsen-Freeman D. 1997. Chaos/complexity science and language acquisition. – Applied Linguistics 18: 141–165.
Maslov J. 1988. Resultative, perfect and aspect. – Nedjalkov V. (ed.). Typology of resultative constructions. Amsterdam, Philadelphia: 63–85.
Richardson K., Cilliers P., Lissack M. 2007. Complexity science: A ‘Gray’ science for the ‘stuff in between’. – Cilliers P. (ed.). Thinking complexity. Mansfield: 25–35.
Smith P. 1998. Explaining chaos. Cambridge.
Strogatz S. 1994. Nonlinear dynamics and chaos: With applications to physics, biology, chemistry, and engineering. New York.
Wagensberg J. 2007. Ideas sobre la complejidad del mundo. Barcelona.