Influence of sensorineural hearing loss on familiar speaker recognition: A forensic perspective on ageing

Jacek Kudera


The main goal of this research was to discover the influence of high frequency sensorineural hearing loss on familiar speaker recognition during earwitnessing line-ups. The secondary objectives were to estimate the influence of familiarity with voices of the suspects on performance in the auditory speaker recognition test, and to correlate the results with forensically important factors such as a confidence scale from the line-up markings. The recordings from the line-up sessions were low-pass filtered to ensure an equal degree of signal distortion for all subjects and imitate the moderate, severe and profound hearing loss conditions. The results show that the correlation between mimicked hearing impairment and ability to identify a familiar speaker is statistically significant. It was observed that higher degree of signal distortion caused lower accu­racy of recognition. Interestingly, it was reported that higher levels of familiarity and exposure to speakers’ voices had a negative effect on speaker identification.

Słowa kluczowe: forensic linguistics, phonetics, presbycusis, earwitnessing, line-up

Agrawal Y., Platz E.A., Niparko J.K. 2008. Prevalence of hearing loss and differences by demographic characteristics among US adults: Data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, 1999–2004. – Archives of Internal Medicine 168.14: 1522–1530.

ASHA Guidelines 1997 = American Speech-Language-Hearing Association. 1997. Guidelines for Audiologic Screening. [].

Balazs P. 2003. Masking filter, phase vocoder and STx – an introduction. – SAMPTA03-Sampling Theory and Applications. [ com_content&view=article&id=46:stools-stx-intelligent-sound- processing&catid= 179&Itemid=854&showall=&limitstart=2&lang=en].

Blevins N., Deschler D., Park L. 2015. Presbycusis. – UpToDate. Waltham (MA). [].

Boersma P., Weenink D. 2018. Praat: Doing phonetics by computer. [Computer program, Version 6.0.40;].

Ciorba A., Bianchini C., Pelucchi S., Pastore A. 2012. The impact of hearing loss on the quality of life of elderly adults. – Clinical Interventions in Aging 7: 159–163.

Cox R.M., Alexander G.C., Beyer C.M. 2003. Norms for the international outcome inventory for hearing aids. – Journal of the American Academy of Audiology 14.8: 403–413.

Cruickshanks K.J., Klein R., Klein B.E., Wiley T.L., Nondahl D.M., Tweed T.S. 1998. Cigarette smoking and hearing loss: The epidemiology of hearing loss study. – Jama 279.21: 1715–1719.

Daniel E. (rev.). 2007. Noise and hearing loss. – Journal of School Health 77.5: 225–231.

Davies-Venn E., Nelson P., Souza P. 2015. Comparing auditory filter bandwidths, spectral ripple modulation detection, spectral ripple discrimination, and speech recognition: Normal and impaired hearing. – The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 138.1: 492–503.

Dawes P., Cruickshanks K.J., Moore D.R., Edmondson-Jones M., McCormack A., Fortnum H., Munro K.J. 2014. Cigarette smoking, passive smoking, alcohol consumption, and hearing loss. – Journal of the Association for Research in Otolaryngology 15.4: 663–674.

de Jong-Lendle G., Nolan F., McDougall K., Hudson T. 2015. Voice lineups: A practical guide. – The Scottish Consortium for ICPhS 2015 (ed.). 18th International Congress of Phonetic Sciences. Glasgow: University of Glasgow. [ proceedings/ ICPhS2015/ Papers/ICPHS0598.pdf].

Demeester K., Van Wieringen A., Hendrickx J.J., Topsakal V., Fransen E., Van Laer L., Van de Heyning P. 2009. Audiometric shape and presbycusis. – International Journal of Audiology 48.4: 222–232.

Divenyi P.L., Stark P.B., Haupt K.M. 2005. Decline of speech understanding and auditory thresholds in the elderly. – The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 118.2: 1089–1100.

Foulkes P., Barron A. 2000. Telephone speaker recognition amongst members of a close social network. – Forensic Linguistics 7: 180–198.

Fransen E., Topsakal V., Hendrickx J.J., Van Laer L., Huyghe J.R., Van Eyken E., Lemkens N., Hannula S., Mäki-Torkko E., Jensen M., Demeester K., Tropitzsch A., Bonaconsa A., Mazzoli M., Esposo A., Verbruggen K., Huygen P.L.M., Kunst S., Manninen M., Diaz-Lacava A., Steffens M., Wienker T.F., Pyykkö I., Cremers C.W.R.J., Kremer H., Dhooge I., Stephens D., Orzan E., Pfister M., Bille M., Parving A., Sorri M., Van de Heyning P., Van Camp G. 2008. Occupational noise, smoking, and a high body mass index are risk factors for age-related hearing impairment and moderate alcohol consumption is protective: A European population-based multicentre study. – Journal of the Association for Research in Otolaryngology 9.3: 264–276.

Frisina R.D., Walton J.P. 2006. Age-related structural and functional changes in the cochlear nucleus. – Hearing Research 216: 216–223.

Füllgrabe C., Moore B.C., Stone M.A. 2015. Age-group differences in speech identification despite matched audiometrically normal hearing: Contributions from auditory temporal processing and cognition. – Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience 6: 1–25. [].

Gates G.A., Caspary D.M., Clark W., Pillsbury III H.C., Brown S.C., Dobie R.A. 1989. Presbycusis. – Otolaryngology – Head and Neck Surgery 100.4: 266–271.

Gates G.A., Mills J.H. 2005. Presbycusis. – The Lancet 366.9491: 1111–1120.

Greenberg S., Ainsworth W.A. 2004. Speech processing in the auditory system: An overview. – Greenberg S., Popper A. (eds.). Speech processing in the auditory system. New York: Springer.

Hautamäki V., Kinnunen T., Nosratighods M., Lee K.A., Ma B., Li H. 2010. Approaching human listener accuracy with modern speaker verification. – INTERSPEECH-2010: 1473–1476.

Hietanen A., Era P., Henrichsen J., Rosenhall U., Sorri M., Heikkinen E. 2005. Hearing among 75-year-old people in three Nordic localities: A comparative study. – International Journal of Audiology 44.9: 500–508.

Hollien H. 1996. Consideration of guidelines for earwitness lineups. – Forensic Linguistics 3: 14–23.

Hollien H. 2002. Forensic Voice Identification. London: Academic Press.

Hollien H. 2012. On earwitness lineups. – Investigative Sciences Journal 4.1: 1–17.

Hollien H., Didla G., Harnsberger J.D., Hollien K.A. 2016. The case for aural perceptual speaker identification. – Forensic Science International 269: 8–20.

Hollien H., Schwartz R. 2000. Aural-perceptual speaker identification: Problems with noncontemporary samples. – Forensic Linguistics 7: 199–211.

Huang Q., Tang J. 2010. Age-related hearing loss or presbycusis. – European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 267.8: 1179–1191.

Kociński J., Ozimek E. 2015. Speech intelligibility in rooms with and without an induction loop for hearing aid users. – Archives of Acoustics 40.1: 51–58.

Leippe M.R., Eisenstadt D., Rauch S.M. 2009. Cueing confidence in eyewitness identifications: Influence of biased lineup instructions and pre-identification memory feedback under varying lineup conditions. – Law and Human Behavior 33.3: 194–212.

Lin F.R., Niparko J.K., Ferrucci L. 2011. Hearing loss prevalence in the United States. –Archives of Internal Medicine 171.20: 1851–1853.

McAuliffe M.J., Wilding P.J., Rickard N.A., O’Beirne G.A. 2012. Effect of speaker age on speech recognition and perceived listening effort in older adults with hearing loss. – Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 55: 838–847.

McClelland E. 2008. Voice recognition within a closed set of family members. [Paper presented at the International Association for Forensic Phonetics and Acoustics Annual Conference, Lausanne, 20–23 July].

Monzani D., Galeazzi G.M., Genovese E., Marrara A., Martini A. 2008. Psychological profile and social behaviour of working adults with mild or moderate hearing loss. – Acta Otorhinolaryngologica Italica 28.2: 61–66.

Moore D.R., Edmondson-Jones M., Dawes P., Fortnum H., McCormack A., Pierzycki R.H., Munro K.J. 2014. Relation between speech-in-noise threshold, hearing loss and cognition from 40–69 years of age. – PLoS ONE 9.9: e107720. [doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0107720].

Nelson E.G., Hinojosa R. 2006. Presbycusis: A human temporal bone study of individuals with downward sloping audiometric patterns of hearing loss and review of the literature. – The Laryngoscope 116 (S112): 1–12.

Newman C.W., Weinstein B.E., Jacobson G.P., Hug G.A. 1990. The hearing handicap inventory for adults: Psychometric adequacy and audiometric correlates. – Ear and Hearing 11.6: 430–433.

Newman C.W., Weinstein B.E., Jacobson G.P., Hug G.A. 1991. Test-retest reliability of the hearing handicap inventory for adults. – Ear and Hearing 12.5: 355–357.

Nolan F. 1991. Forensic phonetics. – Journal of linguistics 27.2: 483–493.

Nolan F.J.D. 1980. The phonetic bases of speaker recognition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Olsson J. 2004. Forensic linguistics: An introduction to language crime and the law. London, New York: Continuum.

Pichora-Fuller M.K., Schneider B.A., Benson N.J., Hamstra S.J., Storzer E. 2006. Effect of age on detection of gaps in speech and nonspeech markers varying in duration and spectral symmetry. – The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 119.2: 1143–1155.

Poortinga W. 2007. The prevalence and clustering of four major lifestyle risk factors in an English adult population. – Preventive Medicine 44.2: 124–128.

Popelka M.M., Cruickshanks K.J., Wiley T.L., Tweed T.S., Klein B.E., Klein R., Nondahl D.M. 2000. Moderate alcohol consumption and hearing loss: A protective effect. – Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 48.10:1273–1278.

Rose P. 2002. Forensic speaker identification. London, New York: Taylor & Francis.

Roth T.N., Hanebuth D., Probst R. (rev.). 2011. Prevalence of age-related hearing loss in Europe. – European Archives of Oto-Rhino-Laryngology 268.8: 1101–1107.

Schroeder M.R. 2013. Computer speech: Recognition, compression, synthesis. [vol. 35]. Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Science & Business Media.

Sigmund M. 2003. Voice recognition by computer. Marburg: Tectum Verlag.

Sørensen M.H. 2012. Voice line-ups: Speakers’ F0 values influence the reliability of voice recognitions. – International Journal of Speech, Language & the Law 19.2: 145–158.

Sprinzl G.M., Riechelmann H. 2010. Current trends in treating hearing loss in elderly people: A review of the technology and treatment options – a mini-review. Gerontology 56.3: 351–358.

Stark P., Hickson L. 2004. Outcomes of hearing aid fitting for older people with hearing impairment and their significant others. – International Journal of Audiology 43.7: 390–398.

Van Eyken E., Van Camp G., Van Laer L. 2007. The complexity of age-related hearing impairment: Contributing environmental and genetic factors. – Audiology and Neurotology 12.6: 345–358.

Weber P.C., Deschler D., Sokol N. 2006. Etiology of hearing loss in adults. – Up-To-Date 13: 3. [].

Wong L.T., Leung L.K. 2005. Minimum fire alarm sound pressure level for elder care centres. – Building and Environment 40.1: 125–133.

Yarmey A.D., Matthys E. 1992. Voice identification of an abductor. – Applied Cognitive Psychology 6: 367–377.

Zetterholm E., Sarwar F., Thorvaldsson V., Allwood C.M. 2012. Earwitnesses: The effect of type of vocal differences on correct identification and confidence accuracy. – International Journal of Speech, Language & the Law 19.2: 219–237.

Czasopismo ukazuje się w sposób ciągły on-line.
Pierwotną i jedyną formą czasopisma jest wersja elektroniczna.