India’s Indo-Pacific Gambit: An Awkward Power Striving for Status

Emilian Kavalski

Abstrakt

It seems that the Indo-Pacific label has been deployed by India to validate its great power aspirations. Such operationalization of strategic region-building acknowledges that the positioning of any international actor emerges as a power in context –it is not entirely an intrinsic property of an actor, but depends on the kind of interactions it has in specific (temporal and spatial) contexts. This condition is one of the key sources of the awkwardness of India’s great power. It reflects simultaneously (i) the contested nature of India’s standing –jostling between an aspiring great power, a regional South Asian hegemon, and a begrudging middle power; and (ii) the neglect of Indian aspirations (and self-perception) of great civilizational state. The paper examines these dynamics by, firstly, deploying a discursive study on foreign policy making, whose framework then provides the analytical backstop to the assessment of Indian foreign policy making in the Indo-Pacific region. As such, the concluding section of the paper suggests that the case of India confirms the assumption that it is the complex interactions between contestation and neglect that frames the awkward status of power on the world stage.

FINANSOWANIE

The author wishes to acknowledge the financial assistance of the NAWA Chair Professor Grant (PPN/PRO/2020/1/00003/DEC/1) from the Polish Academic Exchange Council and NCN grant (ZARZADZENIE NCN 94/2020) from the Polish National Science Council.

Słowa kluczowe: great power, civilizational state, Indian Foreign Policy, Indo-Pacific region, middle power, regional power
References

Abe, Sh. (2007). “Confluence of the Two Seas”. Speech by H.E. Mr. Shinzo Abe, Prime Minister of Japan at the Parliament of the Republic of India. August 22, 2007. Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Japan, http://www.mofa.go.jp/region/asia-paci/pmv0708/speech-2.html (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Acharya, A. (2007). “The Emerging Regional Architecture of World Politics”. World Politics, 59(4), pp. 629–652.

AsiaNews (2020). “New Delhi’s Own ‘Health’Silk Road”. AsiaNews, April 9, http://www.asianews.it/news-en/New-Delhi%E2%80%99s-own-’health’-Silk-Road-49792.html (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Baruah, D. (2020). “India in the Indo-Pacific”. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, Carnegie Working Paper, https://carnegieendowment.org/files/Baruah_UnderstandingIndia_final1.pdf (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Basrur, R. (2011). “India: A Major Power”. In: T.J. Volgy et al. (eds.). Major Powers and the Quest for Status in International Politics. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 181–202.

Bhaskar, C.U. (2020). “What Is India’s Indo-Pacific Strategy?” The National, September 20, https://www.thenationalnews.com/opinion/comment/what-is-india-s-indo-pacific-strategy-1.1080510 (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Bhatia, R. (2019). “The IBSA Task List”. The Hindu, May 22, https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/op-ed/the-ibsa-task-list/article27199570.ece (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Biswas, S. (2020). “Coronavirus: India’s Pandemic Lockdown Turns into a Human Tragedy”.

BBC News, March 30, https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-india-52086274 (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Boesche, R. (2002). The First Great Political Realist: Kautilya and His and Arthashasra. Boulder, CO: Lexington Books.

Campbell, D. (1998). Writing Security. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minneapolis Press.

Chakrabarti, Sh. (2017). “Global South Rhetoric in India’s Policy Projection”. Third World Quarterly, 38(8), pp. 1909–1920.

Chandran, D.S. (2013). “Indian Pivot towards Asia-Pacific”. The Tribune, March 9. Chapnick, A. (1999). “The Middle Power”. Canadian Foreign Policy Journal, 7(2), pp. 73–82.

Chellaney, B. (2020). “The Quad Sharpens Its Edges”. Project Syndicate, October 16, https://www.project-syndicate.org/commentary/the-quad-india-us-japan-australia-united-front-vs-china-by-brahma-chellaney-2020-10 (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Dasgupta, M. (2017). “OBOR Counter? Modi for Asia-Africa Corridor”. The Tribune, May 24, https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/nation/obor-counter-modi--for-asia-africa-corridor-411899 (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Deutsche Welle (2020). “US, India Sign Defense Pact on Sharing Satellite Data”. Deutsche Welle, October 27, https://www.dw.com/en/us-india-sign-defense-pact-on-sharing-satellite-data/a-55404974 (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Diez, Th. (2001). “Europe as a Discursive Battleground”. Cooperation and Conflict, 36(1), pp. 5–38.

Dillon, M. (2004). Xinjiang. London: Routledge.

George, V. (2017). “China a Threat, India an Ally: Trump”. The Hindu, December 20.

Government of India (2011). Census of India 2011. Statement 5: Number of literates and Literacy Rate by sex and residence, http://censusindia.gov.in/2011-prov-results/paper2/data_files/india/Statement5_Literate&LitRate_State.xls (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Gupta, R. (2011). “India Puts the Indo in ‘Indo-Pacific’”. Asia Times, December 8. 

Gurung, Sh.K. (2020). “India, China Increased Nuclear Weapons since Last Year: SIPRI”. The Economic Times, June 16.

Hall, S. (1996). The Question of Cultural Identity. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Hansen, L. (1996). “State Building on the Balkan Border”. Alternatives, 2(4), pp. 473–495.

Horesh, N., Kavalski, E. (2014). Asian Thought on China’s Changing International Relations. Basingstoke: Palgrave.

Ishikawa, J. (2020). “Germany Ends China Honeymoon with New Indo-Pacific Strategy”. Nikkei Asia, September 9, https://asia.nikkei.com/Politics/International-relations/Germany-ends-China-honeymoon-with-new-Indo-Pacific-strategy (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Jordaan, E. (2003). “The Concept of a Middle Power in International Relations: Distinguishing between Emerging and Traditional Middle Powers”. Politikon, 30(1), pp. 165–181.

Joshi, Sh. (2015). “Indian Power Projection: Ambition, Arms and Influence”. Whitehall Papers, 85, December 27.

Kapur, A. (2006). India – From Regional to World Power. London: Routledge.

Katzenstein, P.J. (2005). A World of Regions: Asia and Europe in the American Imperium. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Kavalski, E., Cho, Y.Ch. (2015). “Governing Uncertainty in Turbulent Times”. Comparative Sociology, 14(3), pp. 429–442.

Kavalski, E., Cho, Y.Ch. (2018). “The European Union in Central Eurasia: Still Looking for Strategy”. Asia Europe Journal, 16(1), pp. 51–63.

Kavalski, E. (2002). “Whose Security? Russia in Asia”. Ab Imperio, 3(3), pp. 631–641.

Kavalski, E. (2003). “Whether a Nation and…Whither If One?” Ab Imperio, 4(1), pp. 558–568.

Kavalski, E. (2005). “The Balkans after Iraq, Iraq after the Balkans…Who’s Next?” Perspectives on European Politics and Societies, 6(1), pp. 103–127.

Kavalski, E. (2006). “From the Western Balkans to the Greater Balkans Area”. Mediterranean Quarterly, 17(1), pp. 86–100.

Kavalski, E. (2007a). “Partnership or Rivalry between the EU, China and India in Central Asia: The Normative Power of Regional Actors with Global Aspirations”. European Law Journal, 13(6), pp. 839–856.

Kavalski, E. (2007b). “The Fifth Debate and the Emergence of Complex International Relations Theory”. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 20(3), pp. 435–454.

Kavalski, E. (2007c). “The Complexity of Empire”. Canadian Journal of History, 42(2), pp. 271–280.

Kavalski, E. (2007d). “Whom to Follow? Central Asia between the EU and China”. China Report, 43(1), pp. 43–55.

Kavalski, E. (2008a). “Venus and the Porcupine: Assessing the EU-India Strategic Partnership”. South Asian Survey, 15(1), pp. 63–81.

Kavalski, E (2008b). “The Complexity of Global Security Governance”. Global Society, 22(4), pp. 423–443.

Kavalski, E. (2009a). “Timescapes of Security: Clocks, Clouds, and the Complexity of Security Governance”. World Futures, 65(7), pp. 527–551.

Kavalski, E. (2009b). China and the Global Politics of Regionalization. London: Routledge. Kavalski, E. (2010a). “The Peacock and the Bear in the Heartland: Central Asia and the Shifting Patterns of India’s Relations with Russia”. Indian Journal of Asian Affairs, 23(1/2), pp. 1–20.

Kavalski, E. (2010b). “The Peacock and the Dragon: How to Grapple with the Rising Global Ambitions of India and China”. China Quarterly, 203, pp. 719–724.

Kavalski, E. (2010c). “Uncovering the ‘New’Central Asia: The Dynamics of External Agency in a Turbulent Region”. In: E. Kavalski (ed.). The New Central Asia: The Regional Impact of International Actors. Singapore: World Scientific, pp. 1–25.

Kavalski, E. (2010d). India and Central Asia: The Mythmaking and International Relations of a Rising Power. London: I.B. Tauris.

Kavalski, E. (2011a). “An Elephant in a China Shop? India’s Look North to Central Asia... Seeing only China”. In: M. Laruelle et al. (eds.). China and India in Central Asia: A New “Great Game”? Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 41–60.

Kavalski, E. (2011b). “Looking North: Central Asia and the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation”. In: D. Scott (ed.). Handbook of India’s International Relations. London: Routledge, pp. 201–210.

Kavalski, E. (2012a). Central Asia and the Rise of Normative Powers: Contextualizing the Security Governance of the European Union, China, and India. New York: Bloomsbury. Kavalski, E. (2012b). “Waking IR Up from its ‘Deep Newtonian Slumber’”. Millennium: Journal of International Studies, 41(1), pp. 137–150. 

Kavalski, E. (2012c). “‘Pax Indica’or ‘Brand India’? The Myth of Assertive Posturing in India’s Post-1998 Foreign Policymaking”. Harvard Asia Quarterly, 14(2), pp. 46–51.

Kavalski, E. (2014a). “The Shadows of Normative Power in Asia”. Pacific Focus, 29(3), pp. 303–328.

Kavalski, E. (2014b). “The European Union and India: Birds of a Feather or Frenemies for Ever?”In: P. Winand, A. Benvenuti, I. Guderzo (eds.). The External Relations of the European Union. Berlin: Peter Lang, pp. 151–166.

Kavalski, E. (2015a). Encounters with World Affairs: An Introduction to International Relations. London: Routledge.

Kavalski, E. (2015b). “India’s Bifurcated Look to ‘Central Eurasia’: The Central Asian Republics and Afghanistan”. In: D.M. Malone, C.R. Mohan, S. Raghavan (eds.). The Oxford Handbook of Indian Foreign Policy. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 426–435.

Kavalski, E. (2016a). “Relationality and Its Chinese Characteristics”. The China Quarterly, 226, pp. 551–559.

Kavalski, E. (2016b). “The EU-India Strategic Partnership: Neither Very Strategic, Nor Much of a Partnership”. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 29(1), pp. 192–208.

Kavalski, E. (2017a). “Normative Power Europe and Normative Power China Compared: Towards a Relational Knowledge-Production in International Relations”. Korean Political Science Review, 51(6), pp. 147–170.

Kavalski, E. (2017b). “Recognizing Normative State Action in International Life”. Political Studies Review, 15(2), pp. 231–242.

Kavalski, E. (2017c). “Whether Power Transition and Whither If One?”In: D. Walton, E. Kavalski (eds.). Power Transition in Asia. London: Routledge, pp. 207–221.

Kavalski, E. (2018a). “The Guanxi of Relational International Affairs”. Chinese Political Science Review, 3(3), pp. 233–251.

Kavalski, E. (2018b). “Guanxi or What Is the Chinese for Relational Theory of World Politics”. International Relations of the Asia-Pacific, 18(3), pp. 397–420.

Kavalski, E. (2018c). The Guanxi of Relational International Theory. London: Routledge. 

Kavalski, E. (2019a). “The Puzzle of India’s Relations with Central Eurasia”. Asian Security 15(3), pp. 304–322.

Kavalski, E. (2019b). “India: Breaking Out of the Middle Power Straitjacket?”In: T. Struye de Swielande, D. Vandamme, D. Walton, T. Wilkins (eds.). Rethinking Middle Power in the Indo-Pacific. London: Routledge, pp. 162–173.

Kavalski, E. (2020a). “Inside/Outside and Around: Complexity and the Relational Ethics of Global Life”. Global Society, 34(4), pp. 467–486.

Kavalski, E. (2020b). “The Unexpected Consequences of China’s Cooperation with Central and Eastern Europe”. International Studies, 57(1), pp. 1–19.

Kavalski, E. (2021a). “The End of China’s Romance with Central and Eastern Europe”. Global Media and China, 6(1), pp. 77–99.

Kavalski, E. (2021b). “Quo Vadis Cooperation between China and Eastern Europe in the Era of COVID-19?” World Affairs, 184(1), pp. 33–56.

Kavalski, E. (2021c). “The European Union and India: A Reluctant Partnership between Aspiring Global Powers”. In: L.C. Ferreira-Pereira, M. Smith (eds.). The European Union’s Strategic Partnerships. Basingstoke: Palgrave, pp. 199–200.

Kavalski, E. (2022a). “The Memory Bear”. New Perspectives, 30(2), pp. 148–156. 

Kavalski, E. (2022b). “India: An Awkward Great Power”. In: G. Abbondanza, T.S. Wilkins (eds.). Awkward Powers: Escaping Traditional and Middle Power Theory. Basingstoke: Palgrave, pp. 73–94.

Khilnani, S. (2005). “India as a Bridging Power”. In: P.K. Basu et al. (eds.). India as a New Global Leader. London: The Foreign Policy Centre, pp. 1–15.

Khilnani, S. et al. (2012). Nonalignment 2.0: A Foreign and Strategic Policy for India. New Delhi: Centre for Policy Research.

Lak, D. (2008). India Express. New York: Penguin Viking.

Lake, D., Morgan, P. (1997). “The New Regionalism in Security Affairs”. In: D. Lake, P. Morgan (eds.). Regional Orders. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania State University Press, pp. 3–19.

Lal, R. (2006). Understanding China and India. Westport, CT: Praeger. 

Lowy Institute (n.d.). Asia Power Index: India, https://power.lowyinstitute.org/countries.php?profile=IN (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Markell, P. (2003). Bound by Recognition. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

McCullock, M.R.J., Kavalski, E. (2005). “Back to Althusius: Pre-Westphalian Suggestions for a Post-Westphalian World”. Atlantic Journal of World Affairs, 1(1), pp. 106–127.

Mellor, J.W. (ed.) (1979). India: A Rising Middle Power. Boulder, CO: Westview Press.

Ministry of External Affairs (2015). Joint Statement on India and Japan Vision 2025: Special Strategic and Global Partnership Working Together for Peace and Prosperity of the Indo-Pacific Region and the World (December 12, 2015). Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, December 12, https://www.mea.gov.in/bilateral-documents.htm?dtl/26176/Joint_Statement_on_India_and_Japan_Vision_2025_Special_Strategic_and_Global_Partnership_
Working_Together_for_Peace_and_Prosperity_of_the_IndoPacific_R
(accessed: 1.07.2022).

Ministry of External Affairs (2018). Prime Minister’s Keynote Address at Shangri La Dialogue (June 01, 2018). Ministry of External Affairs, Government of India, June 1, https://www.mea.gov.in/Speeches-Statements.htm?dtl/29943/Prime+Ministers+Keynote+Address+at+Shangri+La+Dialogue+June+01+2018 (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Ministry of External Affairs (2019). Annual Report 2018–2019. Policy Planning and Research Division, Ministry of External Affairs, New Delhi, http://www.mea.gov.in/Uploads/PublicationDocs/31719_MEA_AR18_19.pdf (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Mohan, C.R. (2004). Crossing the Rubicon: The Shaping of India’s New Foreign Policy. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

Mohan, C.R. (2006). “India and the Balance of Power”. Foreign Affairs, 85(4), pp. 17–32.

Munro, R. (1989). “Superpower Rising”. Time, 14 (April 3), pp. 10–17.

Murthy, P.A.N. (ed.) (1986). India and Japan: Dimensions of Their Relations. New Delhi: ABC Publishing House.

Nayar, B.R. (1999). “India as a Limited Challenger?”In: T.V. Paul, J.A. Hall (eds.). International Order and the Future of World Politics. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, pp. 213–233.

Nayar, B.R., Paul, T.V. (2003). India in the World Order. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Nehru, J. (2004). The Discovery of India. New Delhi: Penguin.

Nehru, V. (2013). “The Rebalance to Asia: Why South Asia Matters”. Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, March 13, http://carnegieendowment.org/2013/03/13/rebalance-to-asia-why-south-asia-matters-pub-51197 (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Neumann, I. (1999). Uses of the Other. Manchester: Manchester University Press. 

Ogden, Ch. (2014). Indian Foreign Policy. Cambridge: Polity Press.

Nordin, A., Smith, G., Jackson, P., Kavalski, E., Nexon, D., Qin, Y., Zalewski, M. (2019). “Towards Global Relational Theorizing: A Dialogue between Sinophone and Anglophone  Scholarship on Relationalism”. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 32(5), pp. 570–581.

Ogden, Ch. (2019). “India as a Great Power”. India in Transition Series (Center for the Advanced Study of India, University of Pennsylvania), November 18.

Ollapally, D. (2011). “India: The Ambivalent Power”. International Studies, 48(3–4), pp. 201–222.

Pan, Ch., Kavalski, E. (2018). “Theorizing Rise in and beyond International Relations”. International Relations of the Asia-Pacific, 18(3), pp. 289–311.

Pan, Ch., Kavalski, E. (2022). China’s Rise and Rethinking International Relations. Bristol: Bristol University Press.

Pant, H., Rej, A. (2018). “Is India Ready for the Indo-Pacific?” The Washington Quarterly, 41(2), pp. 47–61.

Pant, H., Sharma, R.K. (2019). “India and Its BRICS Dilemmas”. ORF Commentary, November 18, https://www.orfonline.org/research/india-and-its-brics-dilemmas-57891/ (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Pant, H. (2020). “China, India and their Contending Visions of Global Order”. ORF Commentary, June 29, https://www.orfonline.org/research/china-india-and-their-contending-visions-of-global-order-68692/ (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Pardesi, M. (2015). “Is India a Great Power”. Asian Security, 11(1), pp. 1–30.

Pattanaik, S.S. (2008). “War on Terror and Its Impact on Pakistan’s Kashmir Policy”. Strategic Analysis, 32(3), pp. 389–412.

Paul, T.V. (2003). “Systemic Conditions and Security Cooperation”. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 16(1), pp. 135–154.

Payne, A. (2008). “The G8 in a Changing Global Economic Order”. International Affairs, 84(3), pp. 519–533.

Pempel, T.J. (2005). Remapping East Asia. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.

Perkovich, G. (2003). “Is India a Major Power?” The Washington Quarterly, 27(1), pp. 129–144.

Philip, S. (2020). “Indian Navy Will Push Ahead with Plan for 3rd Aircraft Carrier”. The Print, February 21.

Prys, M. (2012). Redefining Regional Power in International Relations. London: Routledge. 

Rajagopalan, R.P. (2019). “Russia-India-China Trilateral Grouping?” The Diplomat, July 5, https://thediplomat.com/2019/07/russia-india-china-trilateral-grouping-more-than-hype/ (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Rudakowska, A., Kavalski, E. (2021). “China’s Views on the Post-Communist Transitions of the Central and East European Countries”. In: O. Kushnir, O. Pankieiev (eds.). Meandering in Transition. Lanham, MD: Lexington Books, pp. 331–252.

Scott, D. (2012). “India and the Allure of the ‘Indo-Pacific’”. International Studies, 49 (3–4), pp. 165–188.

Singh, A. (2015). “‘Blue-Water’Navies in the Indian Ocean Region”. The Diplomat, January 21.

Singh, N. (2006). India: A Rising Power. New Delhi: Authorspress.

SIPRI (n.d.). SIPRI Military Expenditure Database. Stockholm International Peace Research Institute, https://www.sipri.org/databases/milex (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Suganami, H. (2008). “Narrative Explanation and International Relations: Back to Basics”. Millennium, 37(2), pp. 327–256.

Tellis, A.J. (2005). India as a New Global Power: An Action Agenda for the United States. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

Tellis, A.J. (2016). India as a Leading Power. Washington, DC: Carnegie Endowment for International Peace.

The Hindu (2020). “India, U.S. Ink Strategic Defence Pact”. The Hindu, October 27, https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/india-us-ink-strategic-defence-pact/article32953275.ece (accessed: 1.07.2022).

The Times of India (2017). “Asia-Africa Growth Corridor Launched”. The Times of India, May 25, https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/ahmedabad/asia-africa-growth-corridor-launched/articleshow/58830900.cms (accessed: 1.07.2022).

United Nations (n.d.). World Population Prospects 2019. Department of Economic and Social Affairs, https://population.un.org/wpp/ (accessed: 1.07.2022).

Wæver, O. (1998). Explaining Europe by Decoding Discourses. Copenhagen: Copenhagen Political Studies Press.

Waver, O. (2000). The EU as a Security Actor. London: Routledge.

WID.world (n.d.). World Inequality Database, https://wid.world/world/#sptinc_p99p100_z/US;FR;DE;CN;ZA;GB;WO/last/eu/k/p/yearly/s/false/5.
11/30/curve/false/country
(accessed: 1.07.2022).

Williams, M. (2005). The Realist Tradition and the Limits of International Relations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Zolkos, M., Kavalski, E. (2007). “The Hoax of War”. Journal of Contemporary European Studies, 15(3), pp. 377–393.

Zolkos, M., Kavalski, E. (2008). Defunct Federalisms. London: Routledge.

Zolkos, M., Kavalski, E. (2016). “The Recognition of Nature”. In: P. Hayden, K. Schick (eds.). Recognition of Global Politics. Manchester: Manchester University Press,pp. 139–156.